chrwe wrote on Jul 22nd, 2010 at 10:40pm:Hello David,
thank you for your post. It helped me so much for a moment, until I fell back into fear tonight.
Hi again Christiane,
hang on in there -we're getting through this, and you know that all the folks here are on your side!
Quote: You know, what I just dont understand is why brain damage changes a person totally - the personality changes, the thought patterns change, everything we consider a soul changes. If there is an immortal soul, how can this happen? How? I could cry if I think about this. So many have said that people who suffer from brain damage are suddenly another person. I personally know a few - one man, for example, had his brain tumor discovered only because his wife said "this is not my husband" - and when the brain tumor was removed, the husband she knew returned. Or a man I knew who has been injured in the brain by violence, he did not remember his family, everything that made him “him” was gone with this one sudden act. Or the old people I deal with, who just lie in their beds, not remembering anything, not being able to speak, just like very small babies before our consciousness emerges. Our memories, our ethics, our preferences, our whole personality can be changed with brain changes. I don`t understand how this can fit with an immortal soul! It makes me so sad and afraid. Just google "immortal soul" and "brain damage" together and you will see what I mean.
As I see it, you're forgetting one important point:
you are not your body, you are not your brain, and you are not your thoughts.
Okay, that's three things!
(doh....)
Please be sure and comfortable with the idea that whatever happens to your body does not destroy or take away from the essential you. Yes of course it can disturb any outside observer to see the effects of brain damage.
Here's another analogy (you know by now that I'm a great one for these
)
Imagine the brain as the radio system on a ship: the captain gives his orders to the rest of the crew and they do the rest. Now if that communication system is damaged (brain damage) and the orders coming through are garbled or meaningless it doesn't mean that the captain has gone mad or changed completely into another person.
It's simply that the means of communication has broken down. By your own writings above, when the husband had the tumor removed 'he' came back. The means of communication were restored.
The point here is that he'd never been away in the first place, just that his means of communication had got messed up.
Likewise with old folks who are 'losing it' -I'm guessing that they're beginning to withdraw from this life. There may not be much going on on the surface, but for all you know they may be very active out of body, which would not necessarily show up to the observer.
Maybe someone more experienced on the forum here may like to comment further on this, as I'm only guessing.
Quote:The concept of Occams Razor, which says the easiest explanation is usually true,
to which I would counter with the alternative argument that when all possibilities have been explored, the remaining one -NO MATTER HOW IMPROBABLE- must be the correct one.
Quote: tells me in the face of these things - and in the face of remembering nothingness from dreamless sleep and the two full anaesthesias I had, just a "blank" in my life - it is not possible to believe in a soul besides the brain. Terrible!
Do you remember all your dreams? No -but any good hypnotist might be able to get you to the point where they all come flooding back. I know exactly what you mean -I've had anaesthesia when younger for dental work, and it was total blackness -very disappointing for someone expecting to see anything at all.
However, consider that some things in dreams can be so alien that your brain in analysing them simply can't make head or tail of things ('does not compute'
) and so may blank out or translate the info into nonsense.
There's a bunch of stuff about this in both Bob and Bruce's books which you can investigate anytime.
When I'm doing Hemisync tapes and CDs I more often than not blank out completely. Is that because there's nothing there? No, simply because the weight of evidence in the entire Hemisync and Monroe Institute canon is overwhelmingly against that idea.
'I am more than my physical body....'
So even though I may blank out, I know that part of me is still getting the experience and it's stored in my subconscious mind. It's just frustrating that I can't get a conscious memory. So I'll keep bashing away at it until I finally make the breakthrough. What have I got to lose?
Quote:If there is reincarnation, how can we learn if we do not remember anything?
Ah but we do! Just not in this lifetime.
Also consider the idea that if you remembered all your lifetimes this time around, you might be hamstrung by the weight of knowledge and responsibility. So many lives, so many people to be linked with, so many mistakes
that you'd end up maybe not doing anything!
Quote:Why would we not remember our lessons?
Well, that's supposed to be all part of the fun, trying to work out just what the hell we're here to do!
In my own case I drifted for years wondering just what the hell I was supposed to do. In fact looking back I can see from this perspective that a lot of it was staring me in the face, but my perception AT THAT TIME couldn't see it. (I would so love to go back to around 1971 and do it all right again instead!!!!!
)
Maybe part of the answer is trying to still the mind to the point where you can get inner guidance. It's always there, the point is just hearing it and getting out of our own way for it to come through.
No I haven't mastered that one either!
Sometimes it works, most times not. But the point there is that once you've got that one working, you'll have achieved that on your own. Another success!
One thing I found has helped immeasurably for me are Bach flower remedies (usual disclaimer) particularly in getting me to understand my life's purpose. The only thing I regret is not discovering them earlier and saving a lot of time in the process....
(double doh.....)
Quote:And eastern, traditional belief about reincarnation mostly says there is no individual soul beyond death, it is the "universal consciousness" (brahman) that survives and is changed, not our individual soul. Or so I understand it. The survival and learning of an individual soul, I was told, and the idea that we choose a life is a modern western idea that came up in the seventies. At least so I was told.
Personally, I think that's another belief system. If we are all part of 'god' (to use the only term I can think of at the moment) and all god's creation, and we're all supposed to be linked that way, then how can we NOT survive as an individual soul?
And I have to correct you here: the idea thaat we choose a life is FAR FAR older than the 70s. The U.K. had a Society for Psychic Research in the early part of the 20th century, if not before (Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was just one of the eminent Victorians being associated with this), American Indian lore makes mention of past and future lives and meeting loved ones again, Norse spiritual ideas included this, as I believe was also the case for the Celts Druids and far more.
And of course the Ancient Egyptians were masters of all this stuff!
Do you really believe that this idea would have persisted for so long if there hadn't been some gem of truth behind it? (And I haven't even begun to mention Atlantean lifetimes which I've experience through hypnotic regression.....
)
Did you know that it's been reported that more people on the planet actually believe in reincarnation and life after death than those who don't? Mind you, you won't get that reported on Fox or Sky News, for reasons I outlined in my last reply to you.
Christiane, dear Christiane, please relax. It's all true, it all works, and you simply can't be excluded from it all.
By the way, I thought's just occurred to me:
You requested all this stuff before you were born!! (AAARRGGHHHH!
)
as part of your path.
Quote:I read a lot about reincarnation experiments, and although there are many interesting results, they mostly seem like hypnotic suggestions to me. Some results have been proven to be blatantly false or impossible (wrong historical facts or overlapping "past lives"), memories from books or suggestions (accidentally) from therapists. The thing is that there is so much information across the internet that it is just impossible for me to judge what is true and what isnt.
I met a woman on a TV discussion show about reincarnation. Unfortunately her name escapes me at the moment, but she's a famous example.
Sher's an Irish lady who as a child starting talking about her 'other' family, recalling names, locations, areas, and even drawing pictures of the house she had lived in with her other 'family'. Despite others pooh pooh-ing her claims as delusions, she investigated here dreams and discovered her family from a previous lifetimes, This woman had been the mother of the family in a previous life and died. Here children were all grown up now, but they've accepted this woman as the reincarnation of their mother and rekindled the relationship they had before.
This is all proved and documented, and there's no 'rational' explanation for this woman's knowledge of a family that she's never met or 'read about somewhere' (an oft quoted excuse in these cases).
In India, where they're a lot more open about these ideas, proven reincarnation is far more common. Again here, young children may talk about spouses and children they have elsewhere, which are then investigated and acted upon, AND ACCEPTED AS THE NORM.
One I saw on U.K. tv a few years ago was especially fascinating as the Indian child concerned even had the mark on his head in the exact place where a bullet killed him in the previous life.
Go figure, as they say.......
And don't discount overlapping past lives. As linear time doesn't exist 'over there', you could argue (and some have on this very forum?) that you can be born again before you've died here.
All those hours of watching Star Trek really pay off
Quote: I could believe in a soul so much more if the whole person did not change when the brain is damaged - by dementia, by accidents, by a stroke, you name it. Suddenly, you are "gone" - how can one not be totally gone with death?
See above.
Quote: Why has no paranormal event ever been proved?
Because there's no money to be made out of it?
Mind you, if that's true, why have both the Russian and U.S. armies spent serious amounts of time and money on remote viewers? That's the paranormal, and 'as it's all rubbish and pseudoscience anyway', and by your own words unproven, why bother?
Answer: because it has been proven, and kept quiet about for obvious reasons. There's too much at stake for them to admit it, and it throws the current scientific world view right out of the window as a result.
Just because we don't know the principles, doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
The principles of electricity and nuclear fusion have always existed, Try telling that to the church is the middle ages and you would have been sent to the gallows as being in league with the devil. In these supposedly more enlighten times it's dismissed as 'pseudoscience'.
Quote:Why do my guides, if I have any, not speak to me in ways I can understand and not rationale away? Why all the secrecy and mystery? And why did Jesus cry in his last moments "Oh God, why did you leave me" - that already scared me when I was five years old.
Maybe they are speaking but something's blocking your communication. Maybe you are?
I have the same problem with guides. When I went through a crisis many years ago I decided that my guides had given up on me and gone to the beach instead. I used to refer to my guides as 'you bastards!'
It's got a bit better since then, needless to say
Quote: And before Spooky says anything: Just accepting this is impossible to me, sadly. I wish I could. My life is hell with this, I cannot sleep a single night and I am mostly in fear and despair. Maybe if I had never believed, it would be much easier for me – most atheists just don’t think about death and if they do, they think it`s “peaceful” (how can oblivion and random senselessness be peaceful!). But I used to live in the comfort of a loving God, of a purpose in life, in the security that there is an afterlife - although there have always been nights of doubt since I was a child, it was never this bad. But now I feel like I fell into a bottomless pit. You can probably tell from my posts that I am overtired and really badly off - and I used to be a very rational and spiritual person, always trying to help others and advise them :/.
Hm, while I write this, I get fearful that you will all get angry with me. Let me say again that I do not mean to belittle your beliefs or disprove them, all I am seeking is help. I am so sad, I could just cry and cry. If we just vanish into oblivion, I truly wish I had never been born or died as an innocent child, so as to not experience this terrible fear, sadness and pain.
Please do not get angry with me. I really appreciate your PUL and willingness to help me in this torment. I want to cry at the heavens “I just don’t understand! Please let my soul live! Please, please, please do not make me “rest” eternally. Please speak to me”. And then I feel all alone and desperate. And when I write all this to you, it helps a bit and I hope you have some answers that I cannot find. Thank you all, you ARE helping even if it may seem to you that I revolve in circles endlessly - each new answer helps me a bit to find the light again and each time the questions come anew, but maybe one day the light will stay.
Sadly, I tried but never could OBE or anything similar.
Christiane
Christiane, no-one here's going to get angry with you. A lot of folks here have gone through the same thing in questioning what life and existence is all about and whether any of it has meaning. This is the test we all set for ourselves, and it's a big one to break away from the herd mentality and strike out on (what seems like) your own.
But we're ALL doing it here! otherwise this forum (and no doubt others like it) simply wouldn't exist.
You have the inalienable right to question everything and demand answers. Just consider that the answers might come in ways that you don't expect, and that avenues will open up for you in seemingly random ways -there are no coincidences actually.
And lastly , for now, don't worry about beliefs, They can always be changed in the light of your own experience. Like Bob Monroe said when asked about questions like these: Go find out for yourself. He didn't want to have any dogma about this. If you work it out for yourself then that's perfect for you.
Above all, don't believe a word I write!
If it resonates with you that's fine. If not, that's fine too.
I'm not trying to convert anyone here. These are all ideas for your consideration. What conclusions you come to are entirely up to you. Don't worry, we're all here for you.
Now you're overtired again, so :
GET SOME REST!!
and we'll talk again.
Lots of love as always,
David.
PS. It occurred to me that I don't know where all this stuff is coming from in my replies to you. Maybe your guides are using me to get to you? think about it.
D.