Seems to me that there's no action that's inherently wrong - although some extreme examples would require very exceptional circumstances for them to be truly motivated by the highest good. If that is true then it's possible that a person could commit suicide in order to help others - maybe to provide specific experience, or to teach a lesson, or to avoid being used to do harm. Imagine it's rare though -  it'd require quite a high degree of realisation to be able to consciously and correctly make that judgement.

It can presumably be the result of a premature chucking in of the towel for whatever reason too - perhaps where the individual gets 'stuck' and out of obscuration or errors of judgement or limited insight can't see the way forward. The problem with that is that it seems likely that the result will be rebirth into another life where he/she  will again be confronted by the same issues.

I guess a big question that I don't have a clear answer to is that of whether or not we can be presented with circumstances which are absolutely beyond our ability to handle them and which will drive us to suicide.

Some argue that we're always given the means to handle life's challenges. It's possible though that either egotistically driven unwise actions or the kicking in (ripening) of past karma could mean that this is not always true. I suspect that as ever in this stuff that both can be true and that the answer depends on the view of the individual - the obscured mind can't see a way out or experiences suffering, whereas a more realised person in the same situation can and is relatively unruffled.....

In regression work, we often discover that a suicide to escape a situation simply leads back to that situation in slightly different terms. What is avoided by suicide is options for finding a solution, not getting rid of a problem.

However, were I one of the poor souls being tortured in one of those "non-existent secret internment camps" (or in the grip of the Inquisition, if you prefer) I think that suicide might be a suitable option, because it is of the nature of the problem. But to make it work out usefully, I'd have to choose some other lifestyle next time around, which might be more difficult. The thought of being caught up in a perpetual cycle of torture sounds a bit unattractive.

In the case of incurable illness, rather than being a drag on my family for years, the choice of
euthanasia seems morally appropriate. I have yet to meet such a soul in my practice, so I can't comment on how it looks from the "other side".

d

Hey there,

it is hard to believe that suicide is planned before being born, look at the word itself, it means "to kill oneself". It is rather a self determined decision (I won't say free will, it depends on what has driven one to commit suicide, to speak of mobbing or rapings, there are others involved that speed up such decisions) born from circumstances that slowly damage the mind by psychologic matters, until the will to live is broken. It takes some time until commiting suicide, the very moment is what I would call "mental blackout".
Seems to contradict the self-determinism, but usually people dwell in thoughts about ending life before "leaving".

Seing people violently ripped out of their existence before being determined to go, is always tragic (for us here on c1).

But to pick up a point mentioned here, if commiting suicide, you carry that thoughts away with you at your self-determined transition, so you suffer again from the same set of thoughts. Maybe that is the point to start with, since people who died of accidents seem to be not driven by e.g. worries they had in life.

So suicide cannot be planned, imagine someone from what you call your "disc" has ever started to commit suicide, wouldn't that mean, that the thought of killing oneself (maybe the act of suicide also) has become part of the further incarnations as well?
If it is like this, it would mean that suicide, a self determined transition is intervening the plan, not wanted to be part of it. (I know, it is always easy to talk that way, if looking at the mental state of a person who is willing to do so, the "way out" seems so far away from being able to drop the idea of suicide).

regards,

pulsar