Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 3 ... 5
Send Topic Print
What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists? (Read 29726 times)
Peter
New Member
*
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 10
Felixstowe, Suffolk, UK
Gender: male
What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Mar 6th, 2012 at 9:45am
 
What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?  - ANYONE could've written the Bible!! - In years to come, someone might find a "Harry Potter" book, & start worshipping HIM!! lol - So WHAT proof is there?   Grin
Back to top
 
Peter B Holloway  
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #1 - Mar 6th, 2012 at 2:15pm
 
Hello Peter:

I figure the only way a person could really know is by spiritual experience.  In order to have such experiences a person might have to change his (or her) definitions of what God is.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Oliver
Ex Member


Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #2 - Mar 6th, 2012 at 2:42pm
 
That depends how you define "God".
The "God" of the Old Testament seems to be of 7th rank in the Jewish Angelic Hierarchy, so he would not be "THE ONE AND ONLY GOD", but only "a God", the God of the Israelites.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_angelic_hierarchy

Is God a separate being, as described in the Bible? Then I would recommend to forget about him.
If God is not a separate being, then God is All That Is, which is through and through conscious in every tiny particle and even in empty space, and exactly this all-pervading consciousness may be called "God".
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Just Me
Full Member
***
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 151
Gender: female
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #3 - Mar 6th, 2012 at 2:56pm
 
Hi,

I think it depends on how you define God/god. I don't necessarily believe in the God of the Bible (it's too contradictory) but I believe there is a universal consciousness that connects us all with absolute morality.

Be that as it may, I posed a similar question on a forum using the example of how my family has reinvented history about my grandmother after she passed away. So, if my grandmother, a person I actually knew and witnessed with my own eyes, can be put on a pedestal and "deified," isn't it possible (and probable) that hundreds of centuries time has caused the same thing to happen with Jesus' story?

Personally, I don't see the point in arguing for/against it. There is no absolute way to prove/disprove it so what's the point. There has been enough division and strife over this issue. It's irrelevant. Live well, treat others the way you want to be treated and live a life of pure, unconditional love. The rest of it is just academic (and tiresome).

Kind regards,
mj
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Oliver
Ex Member


Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #4 - Mar 6th, 2012 at 3:59pm
 
i also thought of that, Jesus post-mortem being deified and put on a pedestal.
reading the bible, he does not seem to be sooo much apart from us, still human, including emotions and flaws.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Lights of Love
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 881
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #5 - Mar 6th, 2012 at 4:09pm
 
Yes, Jesus was fully human... and look at all he was able do, the love he taught, and the miracles he performed while being fully human should tell us something about ourselves. If only we truly understood the nature of our being, as he did... the consciousness of this world could certainly be a lot different than what it is.
Back to top
 

Tread softly through life with a tender heart and a gentle, understanding spirit.
 
IP Logged
 
juditha
Ex Member


Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #6 - Mar 6th, 2012 at 4:20pm
 
hi peter I only know from my own experience that God exist.,oneday i was so down,even seriously thinking of suicide,i sat in the church garden planning how i was going to end my life and i was going to do it

At that moment i felt nothing but hate for the whole world,i wanted no part of it anymore,so i decided to go into the church and ask God to forgive for what i was about to do when i reached home.

I sat down in front of Jesus on the cross and i told him ,i could bare it no longer,i could not be in this world any longer,i did not need this world and it did not need me

And then i asked God for forgiveness,i got up and went to go through the door and as i reached the door ,Paul the priest of St Peters church grabbed my arm and said to me,you are going nowhere.

Then we sat down and i told Paul everything that had gone wrong for me divorce hurt pain rejection everything and then he asked me to follow him and he led me to the statue of the mother mary and in front of her statue there were white candles burning,then Paul said a prayer to God to help me with his love and then he placed his hand on my head

Well when he did that,the love that filled my whole body was incredible,i had never in all my life felt love like it ,my whole body was at pure peace and absolutley filled with utter love and i felt at that moment that i was truly at one with God

All the pain and all the hate and suffering i had felt for weeks inside me had gone,it was just replaced completely by love and peace.

Paul hugged me and said he had to help someone else who was crying in the church and as i walked back into the church gardens,everyone i saw go past me,in front of me,i felt nothing but love for these people,i did not know any of them but i loved them,i just felt love only love for everything

As i walked home i felt like my whole soul had been cleansed by God.i have never forgotten this experience and i knew that i had been at one with our dear saviour God.

I have always beleived in God's love and i know he saved me that day.

love and God bless   love juditha
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Oliver
Ex Member


Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #7 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 5:20am
 
Lights of Love wrote on Mar 6th, 2012 at 4:09pm:
Yes, Jesus was fully human... and look at all he was able do, the love he taught, and the miracles he performed while being fully human should tell us something about ourselves. If only we truly understood the nature of our being, as he did... the consciousness of this world could certainly be a lot different than what it is.


...and Jesus himself said that we would do greater things than him!
I interpret it meaning that we shall not put him on a pedestal and wait for his second coming and always think of ourselves as incapable of becoming like him, but find our way to our own spiritual growth, yes, leaning onto him, but not for remaining dependent little children, but for realizing  our full potential, as he did, and more! Smiley
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Peter
New Member
*
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 10
Felixstowe, Suffolk, UK
Gender: male
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #8 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 8:33am
 
Yes, but these are ALL spirital things, - it is NOT absolute PROOF!!  Anyone can have "visions" & believe in this & that, but that is NOT proof!! Anyone can visit a church, then say that they feel "uplifted", but that is NOT proof. - The ONLY proof that I ever believe, is what I SEE with my OWN two eyes!!  I never was a "Bible Basher"!! lol   Grin
Back to top
 
Peter B Holloway  
IP Logged
 
Peter
New Member
*
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 10
Felixstowe, Suffolk, UK
Gender: male
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #9 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 8:41am
 
How can you say that Jesus did this & that? You are only quoting from a book, that ANYONE could have written!! HOW do you know that those "stories" are true? It is only a BOOK!! - As I said before, in years to come, someone might find a "Harry Potter" book, & start believing in HIM!! lol -  I suppose some people have such empty lives, that they have to believe in SOMETHING!! The Bible is as good as any!! lol - I WANT PROOF!!   Grin
Back to top
 
Peter B Holloway  
IP Logged
 
DocM
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 2168
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #10 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 9:09am
 
Peter,

Nothing in this physical world comes with absolute proof.    Many philosophers have gone over this.  Descartes was one of the most famous.  In the end, he couldn't find proof of the existence of anything but his own mind.  "I think therefore I am" came into being.  One can argue that physical senses are not proof of anything as they have to be interpreted by our consciousness.   So when you and I agree on what the color red looks like, we may "see" it differently in our minds - but we would never know. 

So if sensory data is not proof (since it needs to be interpreted) then nothing is provable by your methods. 

You will only know God if you experience God or God's love.   God is not an anthropomorphic Sky-human with a long flowing white beard.  God is the foundation of our being.  If you can feel that, and know it through your own exploration, that will be all the proof you will ever need.

M
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Nanner
Super Member
*****
Offline


Theres only AGAPE

Posts: 764
Hamburg, Germany
Gender: female
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #11 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 3:13pm
 
HI Peter and welcome to the Board..

I find your question "short-put", a bit unconscious... but never the less interesting. As if your awaiting just a short a answer as you formulated your question.

I can share "my take on it", but before I do I would like to generate some general heat within your head, love. Simply by asking a few questions to you.

A Person, you encounter, a stranger .... you dont know, they have never said a word to you, you know nothing of them....

Is this person intelligent or is this person daft? You can`t touch "intelligence", its not something you can hold, see, touch, smell. We have to use the methodes which have been "created over time" inorder to measure "it". There had been many many thousands of years ago... where these technics of measurements were not available. I think you take the knowledge of such, for granted right this min.

But what about this perspective. => Someone whom you feel may be intelligent, may be completely daft ...compared to someone I may think is intelligent, or other way around, eh? So now we are at the divingbord of.. "different take on thing" ie. different Realities...different perspective..

The very fact that you asked the question to begin with, or that it was prompted for you to ask is your innerself "begging for Knowledge".. but Dear, you have already identified that "BOOKS" will be BOOKS, handwritten by man and they are certainly sold best due to ingrediant of highest quality of provacation =>Drama ..

So I hand it to you... you are infact intelligent. But please keep in mind not anyone, simply not everyone can be "an author" either. An Author is "inspired to write"...right? As Example: You know a car runs because its tanked with Gas, has a motor and mechanical parts, its not being "inspired" to do so out of seemingly nothingless, its mechanical and thats why it has "limits in its operation".

So lets get to your kern question. I believe several have tried to explain their take on the subject God.You want "proof"? Yet inorder to even first be able to "see", "hear", "touch", "smell" or even "taste" God, you have to be willing to let go of your "mechanical way of thinking". Simply because it "limits" you. Just as a car can never fly.

You will (and I can promise you such...) will "continue" to have plenty of opportunities to achieve your proof of God, providing you are willing to return to your true nature of "listening". Do your homework, open your heart and you will "get it".. Wink

There are many many lessons as to what God is, and the reason why there are so many ways to attain the knowledge is simple. => Because there are many many many different Souls (Students at different levels of learning just as it is in gradeschool, jr. high and high school, college, univer. )

So if I were to tell you go look into the mirror then you at me, your neighbor, the person in another country , put them "all together" and you will see GOD =>you would call it blasphamy! Right? So now we are back to the "perspective issue" I mentioned above. A really nice testimony for me to come to the basics of understanding had been called "Conversations with God"...You can google it.

Maybe once you`ve broadend yourself through that by means of the basics...you`ll be ready for the next step.. =>ALL of Bruces beautiful testimony. You are clearly ready for it.


Can you proove to me that there is NO GOD?

Maybe the soul whom said the word "God" for the very first time was illiterate and really meant "DoG" (god spelled backwards) and imagine how many times you`ve then been mean to God, simply by yellin at your "dog!"  Huh

Hugs
Nanner

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Oliver
Ex Member


Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #12 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 4:08pm
 
Hi Peter and all,

there is no proof! Smiley
simple as that

It is easy to prove the non-existence of "God" if its concept is like the one that most Christians believe in, because those concepts of God are full of flaws and contradictions.
Their concepts try to concile the idea of an omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent God with the "God" (hebr.: "Elohim" and/or "Yahweh") of the Jewish Bible, the Torah, or Old Testament. This is not possible, because the OT concept says that there is separation between "God" (actually "Elohim" and/or "Yahweh", the term "God" or "Lord" was injected later and replaced the original terms Elohim and Yahweh, which both never meant an omnipresent God) and the world, the people, the devil, etc. etc., hence God cannot be omnipresent, because if God was omnipresent, then God would be everywhere, so also in everything at all times, there could be no separation between God and anything else then, but that would contradict the beliefs and stories of the OT. Q.E.D. Wink

If you look beyond the naive concepts of God, then you can find something if you are doing research on your own, with your own psychical means, that is first-hand experience, using your senses.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk2
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 844
Gender: male
Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #13 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 5:19pm
 
[Oliver:] That depends how you define "God".
The "God" of the Old Testament seems to be of 7th rank in the Jewish Angelic Hierarchy, so he would not be "THE ONE AND ONLY GOD", but only "a God", the God of the Israelites.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_angelic_hierarchy

Is God a separate being, as described in the Bible? Then I would recommend to forget about him.

Your post illustrates the dangers of substituting online sources like Wikipedia for scholarly reading in the field of biblical studies.  Your sources, Maimonides and Jewish Kabbalah stem from the 11th to the 13th centuries CE and have nothing to do with Old Testament teaching.  As for Peter's  request for "absolute proof, " Matthew has exposed the absurdity of that request aptly and succinctly. 

{Peter:] "How can you say that Jesus did this & that? You are only quoting from a book, that ANYONE could have written!!"

Peter, almost everything you say about the Bible is absurd.  You obviously have not read any scholarly New Testament introduction that makes the case for the authorship and eyewitness connection of the various stories about Jesus.  Nor can you justify your pontifications about omniscience, a concept indemic throughout the Old Testament, despite the earlier crude anthropormorphisms.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Oliver
Ex Member


Re: What absolute PROOF is there that GOD exists?
Reply #14 - Mar 7th, 2012 at 5:55pm
 
@Berserk2:
Be it as it may, I have not checked the validity of the source, I read a lot about Kabbalah long time ago.

But what about this: Reading a common Bible, like the NKJV (I happen to have one), what about the personal appearance of "God" in the OT? And the communications and actions of him? (do I need to get into detail?)
Still the Christian churches try to present their God as a) being omnipresent/omnipotent/omniscient and b) being the God of the OT.
How can anyone successfully overlook the sheer amount of blatant contradictions there?
Or how can one explain away these contradictions? Need a lot of creativity to do so.

So my point is that such a God that is both the God of the OT and omnipresent cannot exist.

I would not say that the God of the OT did not exist.
I would not say that an omnipresent/omnipotent/omniscient God does not exist.
But I do say that they cannot be one and the same!
It is simple, basic, plain logic.
Any attempt to explain it away would incur further logical contradictions and would need more attempts to explain those away etc., futile.

My experiences to discuss this conundrum with Christians were mostly same, they always backed out, stopped discussion, got irritated or angry. Fortunately, we have overcome the ages where heretics get burnt alive - at least I hope so.

But I also found a theological commentary on internet that said that God is not omnipresent. If that is so, then other conundrums would result from it.
If God is not omnipresent, then God is also not omnipotent and omniscient.
Then how would one define the term "God"? A supernatural being? Then there may be more than one God? That would explain the hebrew word "Elohim" (a plural for mighty ones), and that the God Yahweh demanded (or commanded) that the Israelite people shall not have other Gods before him, and he said he is a jealous God.
Approaching the concept of God of the OT from that side, would indicate that Yahweh was probably a specimen of an extraterrestrial race which was technologically more advanced, but still very material/physical, nothing spiritual.
I think that would contradict the commonly accepted notion of God as being spiritual, wouldn't it? So there is no way to concile the idea of a Universal God with the God of the OT.

Can anyone think of a way how the God of the Old Testament could be identical to the Universal God which is by definition omnipresent/omnipotent/omniscient?
If there would be a way out of that conundrum, I would have food for thought for a long while.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 ... 5
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.