Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
My problems with Karma and Reincarnation (Read 7490 times)
Alan McDougall
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 2104
South Africa
Gender: male
My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Apr 14th, 2010 at 4:39am
 
Some thoughts on reincarnation from an atheistic forum

But let's assume that the soul does exist and inhabits a new body when the old one dies. Why does the soul forget its past experiences? What would make the soul's memories stop when the old body dies? Why would the self - the presumed soul - not be able to remember? Is the soul not the ultimate self? Why would a new body limit the self's ability to conjure its own memories? And for those who claim that déjà-vu or whatever is repressed past memories, I might ask what the mechanism is for memories to be blocked or let through. If they are blocked, how are they getting through? Why can't they all get through?

And if you’re old memories are lost forever, then what is the point of being reincarnated? The point of reincarnation is to extend life, but if you can't retain memories or lessons or knowledge from those past lives, how exactly have you extended your life? It's not much better than saying you achieve immortality by living on in the hearts and minds of your friends. I want to live forever by living forever. I don't want some memory or trace of me living on.

Now for the practical problems of reincarnation. (We'll just deal with humans for right now). Where were all the souls before the earth existed? Where will they go when the earth is destroyed? Will they continue to exist and be sentient, to interact in soul-land? Then why come into bodies at all? And then what if the ratio of bodies-to-souls is off, say more souls than bodies? Do the souls just hang out in soul-land waiting for a new body to inhabit? Or what if there are more bodies than souls? Are new souls born? Or are there some people who are just automatons - functioning robots without souls at all? Could we tell the automatons apart from the real people?

Now let's deal with animals, if you accept trans-special reincarnation. Clearly some animals have different sorts of mental functioning abilities. We can reason better, rats can discern smells better, bats can hear better. Different animals can see in different colors, very much a mental process of the mind. How does the soul make up for these things? When we get transferred to a chicken, do we lose our ability to reason? When we are transferred out of a wolf, do we lose the knowledge of how to hunt? Are our souls restricted in what they can express on their host? And then of course, what's the cutoff point of creatures imbued with souls? Do rats have souls? Bees? Roaches? Bacteria? Viruses? Replicating proteins like Mad Cow? Even if you restrict reincarnation to just humans; at what point in the human evolutionary chain was the first soul imbued?

Now how about the idea that the creature you get to inhabit depends on how good you were in your past life. Who keeps track? Who is the great record-keeper that sends you to your new body? What criteria are used? Is it objective - could it be objective? Does it make mistakes? How does it force our souls into the hosts? Could the soul refuse? And you have to wonder; is your fate graded on a curve? What if everyone in one generation acts perfectly and kindly and loving to everyone? Surely the less desirable bodies are still being born and need to be inhabited. Would a couple of hugs be the difference between a hawk and a slug?

Blessings nd light

Alan

Any comments Alan

Back to top
 

Blessings and Light

Alan McDougall
WWW <a href= <a href=  
IP Logged
 
usetawuz
Senior Member
****
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 397
ne fla
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #1 - Apr 15th, 2010 at 10:55am
 
Interesting Alan.  Early in my quest I asked alot of those same questions, however my experiences have provided answers that the author may not be ready to believe...not that he can't, but rather because he shouldn't.  It may not be his time or meet his soul's intent at this time or this life.  Some are here for different reasons, and this might not be his.  In my mind, I have been shown and have experienced things that give me complete faith in reincarnation and the afterlife and in the "system" I have discussed in other threads here.  I know it doesn't work for all, and I have no problem qualifying my beliefs as my own and no one elses.  But like any belief or opinion, one must rely on faith and an internal understanding of what one feels is right...the tangible evidence, the physical proof, the certifiable facts that will enable all to verify reincarnation and the afterlife as a reality will not emerge until we each pass this dimension.

I don't believe in soul transmigration which takes up his final two paragraphs, but whatever...I have my answers to his initial posits, and am comfortable with that. 

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Beau
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1176
Greenville SC
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #2 - Apr 15th, 2010 at 11:44am
 
Interesting Alan,

Here's what I think: Our decision space is limited by our physical brains. So for me that explains the animal bit. And about the reason we only remember fragments if anything of each lifetime would possibly be because this life is a dream for the higher self. I don't know about you but I don't remember one dream very often when I'm in another dream at a later time. I don't know, of course, anymore than I know much of anything, but it makes as much sense to me as sitting around after this life. I see evolution of the spirit as the only possible answer with any meaning. I'm not crazy about the idea of coming back here, but hey; if I'm not ready to move on I guess I'll take another round.
Back to top
 

All the world's a stage...whose stage?--that is the question!...or is it the answer...Who is on first.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
StoneColdTrue
Full Member
***
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 237
Birmingham, AL
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #3 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 2:14am
 
I did a bit of thinking about this system today. I haven't really enjoyed the idea of reincarnation, but using my conscious thoughts I see things in my life where it could make sense and that me not liking it is just ego anyway. So it really doesn't matter whether I like it or not, because whatever is inevitable will be inevitable. I don't know yet for a fact that reincarnation is a process, but I have to be open to it just because of that.

So here's kind of my current understanding of it, and anyone please feel free comment and/or correct me.

The actual "human being" is the soul. That is our true nature and our true form. The "afterlife" is our actual domain, which is basically a place of energy and matter which can be willed to appear as the soul wishes, pending upon the state of the soul mind. But souls do not progress the same way there as we do in the physical world, so we become part of the physical world because it was created as a training ground for the soul.

We might of course have to question "who or what created the soul and where did it come from?" Those are questions for later, much like finding the nature of what we refer to as "God."

Every generation contains both new and old souls. I think it's quite safe to say there are plenty of people whose souls are experiencing their first time on Earth. This would answer a lot of questions I have had on people's states of mind and consciousness. Before a new or old soul incarnates, they should have a general plan for what they want to accomplish.

The soul incarnates into a physical body and begins with a fresh mind. This happens because it's the most practical way to learn. If we were to begin with an understanding of our true form, it would impair the learning and the experience of the life. The soul lives out its human existence and it may or may not ever reach a high conscious before the body dies. The soul then gets a life review and analyzes what it learned and what it needs to learn or would now like to experience. Reincarnation.

Souls have a certain frequency and because souls/humans are social creatures, we tend to stay together. I've heard a good bit about and read about having a higher connection with the people in your life. The old souls in your life were in your life before. The new souls are likely to be with you should you reincarnate in the next life. This is a very interesting system if you maybe think about your parents.

I don't feel like my parents are even close to my level of consciousness or spirituality. They pretty much just live life. I had first thought this meant my soul was older than theirs but now I see it doesn't really work like that. When they reincarnate they will probably reach a higher consciousness faster than I did. You can see that newer generations are getting smarter and they progress fast...one could say that technology and advancement of the world is what contributes to that but technology and advancement is connected to us. It serves a purpose as we do, more than just entertainment. If I have a child, it may contain a new soul or an old soul. Probably will depend on how I attribute to its plan.

Now I have thought a bit about new souls, and how they wouldn't be able to experience like old souls because they didn't live life in specific periods of time. I've heard about periods of the past still existing in other dimensions of the afterlife, so perhaps a new soul is allowed to venture there if it wishes. Theres still some contradiction to how that could work...or all souls only experience in this dimension only. There is certainly plenty of cultures and places in the world so incredibly different that not living in the past wouldn't affect experience.

So I suppose we keep reincarnating until we no longer want to. Free will still exists. One might say then "well then I'm not going to reincarnate." That's a premature thought. You'll have a different outlook once you have died and understood. But there are the arrogant, unwilling, and confused. Say hello to ghosts. They'll do their thing until some business is attended to or they quit acting like it isn't real.

But eventually, we will have progressed the soul to the point that it's done with the training ground. I imagine that the more consciousness and spirituality (absent of religion) that one achieves, the closer it may understand not wanting to reincarnate and continue progress in the afterlife.

That's basically what I've come to understand thus far, and I have no idea how accurate it is so fire away.



Back to top
 

"The good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge. " -Bertrand Russel
 
IP Logged
 
Beau
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1176
Greenville SC
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #4 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 5:41am
 
Stone,

I think your thoughts on this are excellent. It feels like I am growing more and more from reading your posts. It is very cool to be able to kind of watch you reason things out for yourself, because it surely helps me to reason too. Thank you.

Yours,
Beau
Back to top
 

All the world's a stage...whose stage?--that is the question!...or is it the answer...Who is on first.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
StoneColdTrue
Full Member
***
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 237
Birmingham, AL
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #5 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 11:37am
 
Thank you, Beau. That means a lot. This has all been pretty substantial to my life because at the beginning of this year I had none of these concepts or understandings. This is the most remarkable thing to me because I was an atheist for half of my life, an agnostic without spirituality for over a year up until this year, and now I have this incredible assurance in my spirituality.

This forum has helped me to deepen my thoughts, and allow me to develop. Just look at where I've come from my very first post. I write a lot but its necessary for my expression. I feel part of my purpose for my discovering isn't just for me, but to assist other people. I decided about a month ago I was going to start processing a book for the purpose of inspiring my generation and all others who would find it beneficial to their lives.

We have a great power with thought and it is best utilized when focused away from the self. I see now that all of the events of my life were leading me to this moment. Suddenly everything makes sense, and I knew all along I was on the right path. Even the unplanned events make a difference.

If we need to simplify it all, I think what we can truly understand is that the constant aspect of everything in life is change and improvement. If someone ever asks what our purpose is and why we exist and all those philosophical questions...well I can't feel more confident than that answer. Improvement.

Also Beau, your actor/self metaphor was the first time I had seen it and I found it to be pretty inspiring. I'm a big fan of metaphors because they're the easiest way to help people understand things. It was your personal elaboration that assisted my perspective and I've started to present it to people, because even from outside a spiritual standpoint it can give perspective on just a different and better way to view life.
Back to top
 

"The good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge. " -Bertrand Russel
 
IP Logged
 
Beau
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1176
Greenville SC
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #6 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 11:51am
 
And thank YOU, Stone. I'm on page 30 of my book, but it needs some serious editing already Cheesy

I'm glad you like the Actor metaphor model. I guess the biggest problem with it is that not everyone has been an actor so some things could be hard to relate to without some imagination but I keep plugging along with it. I've noticed a lot of growth in your posts too since you got here. I don't know what you're reading these days but I would highly suggest giving Tom Campbell's My Big TOE a read when you have the chance if you haven't already. It's the most scientific approach to an explanation of EVERYTHING that I've come across so far. I'm reading some Seth right now and checking out some of Peter Russel's stuff too. It all seems to be coming from the same place and that gives me some comfort.

Yours,
Beau
Back to top
 

All the world's a stage...whose stage?--that is the question!...or is it the answer...Who is on first.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
StoneColdTrue
Full Member
***
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 237
Birmingham, AL
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #7 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 12:32pm
 
I definitely need to start doing some reading. I have actually done none other than websites and internet research. It's next on the list. It's easier for me to concentrate directly on my conscious thoughts for now while also dealing with my personal responsibilities.

As for the metaphor, I think it still works without even having a spiritual understanding. I have a lot of people on my frequency who are not spiritual and presenting anything beyond the physical world either confuses them or they just  refuse to listen. But I've considered that metaphor just as a means for allowing a non spiritual person to see how they can take control of their life and quit moping through it.

I presented it to a guy without any hints that the actor was the soul, but instead presented it as just a general metaphor for increasing consciousness and understanding how he could make sense of and enhance his life by keeping the metaphor in his conscious.

Like instead of thinking that your life is beyond your control and allowing the woes of society to drag you down, recognize that the environment of your life is only a stage set up and your job is to act impromptu. I even told him that life is difficult to the same extent of having to be on a stage and perform impromptu for an audience. There is a lot of pressure there, but even more pressure if he doesn't even recognize that he is in control. That's the beauty of the performance after all. The stage and the other characters may be beyond your control, but you get to decide your own script.

Life sucks because we make it suck. It's all in the power of the mind. If you're going to let life beat you, then you are accepting weakness. Take control of your life and become the actor and give the performance you believe is the most suitable for your character and know beforehand that no great story is without drama, so expect it and deal with it. 

He thought it was an interesting way to look at life. It will sink in one of these days.
Back to top
 

"The good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge. " -Bertrand Russel
 
IP Logged
 
Beau
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1176
Greenville SC
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #8 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 1:11pm
 
Excellent. I have some other insights that wrote out a few months ago, but I can't remember what I titled them using language, particularly the spoken word as a metaphor for constant reminding of the script of our own making. I'll try to find the link, unless you already caught it by doing a search or something. I think I wrote it in December and it was a little off topic to some so it may have been moved from this section of the forum. It was the beginning to my Theory of Everything. I'm still working it out. Glad you reached your friend with Actor model. I've had some luck with that too lately. I guess I'm getting better at explaining it as I keep plunging into it.

Yours,
Beau
Back to top
 

All the world's a stage...whose stage?--that is the question!...or is it the answer...Who is on first.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
usetawuz
Senior Member
****
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 397
ne fla
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #9 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 1:28pm
 
Again I italicise my comments to your missive...

StoneColdTrue wrote on Apr 16th, 2010 at 2:14am:
The actual "human being" is the soul. That is our true nature and our true form. The "afterlife" is our actual domain, which is basically a place of energy and matter which can be willed to appear as the soul wishes, pending upon the state of the soul mind. But souls do not progress the same way there as we do in the physical world, so we become part of the physical world because it was created as a training ground for the soul.

I think the human being is simply the biological species the soul infuses with its individuality...our soul can infuse its individuality into other species in other dimensions or realms to achieve the same kind of experience of separation...and the rest I am with you.

Every generation contains both new and old souls. I think it's quite safe to say there are plenty of people whose souls are experiencing their first time on Earth. This would answer a lot of questions I have had on people's states of mind and consciousness. Before a new or old soul incarnates, they should have a general plan for what they want to accomplish.

I can't see the significance of a generational divide between new and old souls...they all exist here concurrently, and while some may be new, it doesn't mean that they are not advanced with much experience in other realms.  Souls experiencing difficulty may be new or advanced souls encountering problems with their connection to their human bodies, the unfamiliarity with the density and intensity of life on earth...any number of things.

The soul incarnates into a physical body and begins with a fresh mind. This happens because it's the most practical way to learn. If we were to begin with an understanding of our true form, it would impair the learning and the experience of the life. The soul lives out its human existence and it may or may not ever reach a high conscious before the body dies. The soul then gets a life review and analyzes what it learned and what it needs to learn or would now like to experience. Reincarnation.

Reaching a consciousness of our souls and afterlife may not be a part of the lifeplan of those souls who are seemingly uninterested or opposed to it...it doesn't mean they don't get to live the truth of the matter anyway.  They just don't take that path this time around.

Souls have a certain frequency and because souls/humans are social creatures, we tend to stay together. I've heard a good bit about and read about having a higher connection with the people in your life. The old souls in your life were in your life before. The new souls are likely to be with you should you reincarnate in the next life. This is a very interesting system if you maybe think about your parents.

We identify soulmates incarnate with vibration...love at first sight, instant connection with friends, etc...and yes, we tend to stay together in groups...my wife has been my wife, mother, daughter, son, brother, sister, etc...and there are many others currently incarnate with whom I've played various roles...and you have, too.

I don't feel like my parents are even close to my level of consciousness or spirituality. They pretty much just live life. I had first thought this meant my soul was older than theirs but now I see it doesn't really work like that. When they reincarnate they will probably reach a higher consciousness faster than I did. You can see that newer generations are getting smarter and they progress fast...one could say that technology and advancement of the world is what contributes to that but technology and advancement is connected to us. It serves a purpose as we do, more than just entertainment. If I have a child, it may contain a new soul or an old soul. Probably will depend on how I attribute to its plan.

Consciousness of the afterlife and spirituality may not be part of your parents lifeplan this time...but it certainly appears to be part of yours! I don't think it is a new/old soul matter though...one can have an advanced new soul or a recalcitrant old soul, with the same goal to be to live what appears to be a basic lifetime without earth-shaking discoveries.  Also, I do not think there is any direct correlation between spiritual advancement and tech advancement.  I do think the newer generations of children (indigo children) are wired differently to allow greater interdimensional understanding (and may be the capacity to extrapolate that into higher technology), but this is more a biological improvement than a spirit/soul improvement...the soul takes the body as he gets it and uses it to the capacity it can handle.

Now I have thought a bit about new souls, and how they wouldn't be able to experience like old souls because they didn't live life in specific periods of time. I've heard about periods of the past still existing in other dimensions of the afterlife, so perhaps a new soul is allowed to venture there if it wishes. Theres still some contradiction to how that could work...or all souls only experience in this dimension only. There is certainly plenty of cultures and places in the world so incredibly different that not living in the past wouldn't affect experience.

A soul can be new to earth and still be advanced, having lived only a single or even a few lives here, while a soul having lived here for hundreds of lives may not have attained a great deal of achievement toward the source...free will, you know.  Time spent on earth and/or time spent in specific eras on earth do not denote advancement...it is based on how that time, either on earth or in other realms was used by the soul.

So I suppose we keep reincarnating until we no longer want to. Free will still exists. One might say then "well then I'm not going to reincarnate." That's a premature thought. You'll have a different outlook once you have died and understood. But there are the arrogant, unwilling, and confused.

Yes...

But eventually, we will have progressed the soul to the point that it's done with the training ground. I imagine that the more consciousness and spirituality (absent of religion) that one achieves, the closer it may understand not wanting to reincarnate and continue progress in the afterlife.

And yes...

That's basically what I've come to understand thus far, and I have no idea how accurate it is so fire away.

My above italicised comments are meant as clarification or amplification of my understanding of the topics you discussed...again, I am not saying you are wrong and I am right...this is just the way I see it.  The beauty is that our understanding can change as we learn more, from whatever source.  Look for statements, comments, and impressions that feel warm when you hear them, as they indicate a truth that resonates within your soul and is trying to tell you something.   




I hope this helps...again, no judgment, just thoughts and ideas!
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Beau
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1176
Greenville SC
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #10 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 2:40pm
 
There are some excellent points in there usetawuz!
Back to top
 

All the world's a stage...whose stage?--that is the question!...or is it the answer...Who is on first.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
usetawuz
Senior Member
****
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 397
ne fla
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #11 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 3:27pm
 
Thanks, Beau.  Stone did the heavy lifting, but I think the picture is becoming pretty clear.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
StoneColdTrue
Full Member
***
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 237
Birmingham, AL
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #12 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 8:15pm
 
Yeah thanks for the comments, buddy. Comments to your comments via hypens for each one.

-I'll agree with you on the human being deal. Perhaps just "being" will do. Not so sure about the other dimensions or realities. I'd prefer to just concentrate on this universe and planet and what all is attached to it. This could very well change, but for now I'm not quite thinking that far ahead.

-Population plays its part. I'm not going into other worlds theory to account for souls. It's also possible that animals play a role. I've imagined maybe all souls begin inhabiting animals before they get to the human being. Perhaps this is restricted to mammals, or perhaps not. I've wondered if its possible for a human being to exist without a soul and thus only nature really animates it. With the amount of deaths and births daily, theres plenty going on with the system.

-I don't imagine every soul actually completes everything it has planned, or that life is carried out by a narrative written beforehand. The soul gets the ideas of what it wants to learn and experience, but it couldn't do that if the entire life was already planned. The whole point is that its all uniquely fresh from birth to death. I think consciousness plays a large part in the lives of all souls, for if we are able to obtain our relationship back to the soul within life, then the soul has obviously made great progress throughout its journey.

-Seems true enough. Though I have to wonder about a certain someone, who had a large affect on me and then disappeared from my life. I've never been able to successfully forget her even though I feel like thats the best idea. I don't even understand it, but if she happens back into my life somehow then I may understand. If not, i'll have to consider myself silly. Theres one guy who he and I see eye to eye on all of this and though we have never been best friends, I've known him since kindergarten. So theres definitely a connection there and we plan on figuring it out.

-I think it makes pretty good sense how that would work though. It's kind of leap frog. One hops over the other and it continues until the first one finds the pond. My dad is definitely coming back here. He has a great deal to learn. And the correlation I see with tech advancement is that there is a great deal of tech available which can help one acquire higher consciousness. The internet for one is incredibly valuable and a luxury that didn't exist at one point for a few of us.

-This is kind of why I think souls play a part in animals first. Anything I feel that can show and understand love surely warrants a soul.

We're all here to learn and grow. That's best done with each other.

Back to top
 

"The good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge. " -Bertrand Russel
 
IP Logged
 
Beau
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1176
Greenville SC
Gender: male
Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #13 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 8:28pm
 
I would only comment on the animal stuff. To me, Consciousness is consciousness no matter what. A dog appears to have a less developed consciousness because it's brain only allows for so much decision space, but place that consciousness in a machine (brain) with a larger decision space and you've got a human. I think we are more than just ourselves and all creatures share this thing called consciousness at every level. I hope that's clear. If not I'll try to find some stuff that Tom Campbell writes on his board because this subject comes up there from time to time.

Yours,
Beau
Back to top
 

All the world's a stage...whose stage?--that is the question!...or is it the answer...Who is on first.
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Starcraft
Ex Member


Re: My problems with Karma and Reincarnation
Reply #14 - Apr 16th, 2010 at 9:09pm
 
I am pretty sure all beings have a consciousness... even insects.

But.....yeah......um......

I bet it sucks to be an insect.

Wink
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.