It will still be the tip of the iceberg no matter how far along you get, I predict. I don't think anyone else is judging us, just the Actor within. And I am certainly not worthy to judge stone and george and besides my hands are full working on myself.

George, I don't think it is possible to relive the same lifetime in the same body...to basically rewind a life and do it again.  It may be possible to energetically recreate certain portions of it, but to re-do it in a human body does not fit anything I understand.

It seems to me that even while theories abound regarding all chronological time to actually have already occurred in an instant, and despite the understanding that as we live out our lives in chronological time, we are simply filling in the blanks with our free will in events that have already substantially occurred, there would be even less opportunity to relive an already lived life.

Regardless, I do not think anything you do, think, feel, say, hear, as George, or any other  incarnate entity you have ever been, is ever forgotten by your soul.  I mentioned in another thread that during past life meditation I apparently view my past life from the standpoint of my soul...I can see all around me as the incarnate entity...I can see both what the entity saw as well as the entity while he was looking at it...I could feel the emotions felt by the entity, I could feel emotions, thoughts and feelings that the entity had no concept of at the time or ever.  We as incarnate human beings are receptive devices that give the soul a great deal more information than we can conceive or process with our human brains.  (an interesting note:  while observing my previous entities, the entity was never aware of all the beings/souls surrounding him at all times, and sometimes only two or three, but often eight or ten and sometimes more...me as the being never saw them but as a soul I could, and they showered love on the being at all times...we are never alone and unloved) We are providing our soul with unbelieveble levels of information and experiential data from which to draw, inspire and grow.  Your incarnate being is a limited, physical biological entity animated with an eternal soul which has received information from probably thousands of previous bodies...the information your soul holds is absolutely inconceivable to our human perception, but it all becomes clear upon our passing as you become the real and full you, your soul...and not restricted by your physical confines. 

This is my two cents on an interesting topic and thank you for posting it.