Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall (Read 12526 times)
george stone
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 857
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #15 - Mar 12th, 2010 at 2:16pm
 
Stand away from your computer and you will see it,my cleaning lady could see it.its all on the left side of the message.George
Back to top
 
WWW  
IP Logged
 
vagabound
Ex Member


Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #16 - Mar 12th, 2010 at 6:33pm
 
Well, you're saying the spaces between the words make the pictures.
These pictures will disappear if you resize the window, because the words will be at a different spot.
That's why we can only see the picture you're describing if our browser windows have the same width as yours.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk2
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 844
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #17 - Mar 21st, 2010 at 10:01pm
 
As a psychiatrist, Dr. Ian Stevenson has studied the research showing that hypnotic regression is not a reliable tool for regressions to early childhood, let alone past life recall (see my first post).  But he is also aware of the fascinating sources of false memory of past lives.  For example, he points to a  case in which a woman vividly remembers a past life in detail.  In fact, her past life recall drew the name and details from a novel in her house whose pages she had flipped through, but which she denied reading.   What started the New Age past life craze" was a book entitled "The Search for Bridey Murphy (1956)."  The subject, Virginia Tighe, both scored hists and made errors.  But cryptonesia is again involved because it was later discovered that a woman named BHridely Murphey Corkell had lived across the street where Virginia had grown up. 

Neither do Stevenson's own cases of the past life recall of young children fare any better.  In 2 of his cases, it can be shown that the prior personality was still allive AFTER the birth of the child who alleges past life recall.  Nor will it do to invoke the dubious notion of parallel incarnations to escape the force of this criticism.  This alternative misses the point that the deceased personality had just died recently and this suggests that 2 newly dead people wanted to almost immediately re-enter earth life and so they did so through possession and not through reincarnation.  Remember, it is widely recognized that the memories of possessing entities seem to the possessed to be their own memories!  This insight vindicates Swedenborg's astral discovery that astral past life recall is rather a case of spirit merger in which the explorer is unaware of the invasive discarnate spirit's presence and that spirit's memories are mistakan for past life memories. 

Don
 
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
spooky2
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 2368
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #18 - Mar 21st, 2010 at 11:02pm
 
I remember an interesting story of someone who recalled an attack from an airplane in WWII back when he was a boy. It had been a single fighter shooting at him with a machine gun, and he hid in a ditch beside the street. Many years later he went to a cinema to watch an old movie. How baffled he was when he saw this very scene in that movie! He figured then, he had seen this movie earlier, not long after WWII and this scene of the movie melted together with a real attack. So, hidden memories, and even false memories are a factor.

However, when we furthermore consider the possibility that so-called past-life memories could be actually picked-up memories of someone else, then a proof of reincarnation is impossible, as I can't see how one discerns an own memory and a memory of someone else which appears as an own memory.

Spooky
Back to top
 

"I'm going where the pavement turns to sand"&&Neil Young, "Thrasher"
 
IP Logged
 
StoneColdTrue
Full Member
***
Offline


ALK Member

Posts: 237
Birmingham, AL
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #19 - Mar 22nd, 2010 at 1:05am
 
spooky2 wrote on Mar 21st, 2010 at 11:02pm:
I remember an interesting story of someone who recalled an attack from an airplane in WWII back when he was a boy. It had been a single fighter shooting at him with a machine gun, and he hid in a ditch beside the street. Many years later he went to a cinema to watch an old movie. How baffled he was when he saw this very scene in that movie! He figured then, he had seen this movie earlier, not long after WWII and this scene of the movie melted together with a real attack. So, hidden memories, and even false memories are a factor.

However, when we furthermore consider the possibility that so-called past-life memories could be actually picked-up memories of someone else, then a proof of reincarnation is impossible, as I can't see how one discerns an own memory and a memory of someone else which appears as an own memory.

Spooky


That's pretty interesting. This kind of strikes a chord with me. Back in 2007, I was sleeping and had my very first lucid dream. In the dream I was in a large city and visited a sports bar. I can remember pretty vividly the way it looked. The first floor included a dancing area, tables to eat at, and a large bar. The top floor was more of a lounge area with rooms which included traditional games, arcade games, and a TV room. You could also order food from up there. I'll skip the other details of the dream.

But towards the end everyone started running and screaming. I was on the top floor which could actually lead outside to a balcony. We all looked up and saw jets flying over our heads and lots of explosions going on. The last thing I remember was looking at a single object flying directly up and exploding bringing chaos down upon all of us. I woke up at that point so out of breath I fell into my wall when I got up. It was intense.

Later that day I went to see Transformers and it featured a trailer for Cloverfield, which had a scene in the trailer that looked so much like the end of my dream that it sent chills through me.

Just wanted to share.  Cheesy
Back to top
 

"The good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge. " -Bertrand Russel
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk2
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 844
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #20 - Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:14am
 
With the frequent dogmatic allusions to "the Jesus Disk,' this seems a good time to revisit the discussion of my critique of past life recall as evidence for reincarnation.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #21 - Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:42pm
 
People have dogmatic viewpoints partly because they listen to what other people have to say without having any experience that collaborate such viewpoints. It is easier to get people to follow such dogma if in some way you fear them into doing so.

On the other hand, some people believe in the Disk viewpoint because they "had" experiences that collaborated such a viewpoint.

Regarding such experiences being nothing more than imagination that is triggured by what somebody like Bruce has to say about the matter, it is possible to have the viewpoint validated in a way where it seems clear that this isn't the case.

There is also the matter of Bruce having a Disk vision before reading of such a thing. Ron Kruger had an NDE where he experienced his greater self in such a way, even though he didn't read or hear about such a thing beforehand. P.M.H. Atwater and Tom Sawyer experienced their greater self in such a way during their NDEs.

I know of another man, I can't remember his name at this time, shortly after World War two he also had a vision where he found out  about things such as Oversouls without having first read or heard of such a thing.

Berserk2 wrote on Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:14am:
With the frequent dogmatic allusions to "the Jesus Disk,' this seems a good time to revisit the discussion of my critique of past life recall as evidence for reincarnation. 

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #22 - Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:45pm
 
recoverer wrote on Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:42pm:
People have dogmatic viewpoints partly because they listen to what other people have to say without having any experience that collaborate such viewpoints. It is easier to get people to follow such dogma if in some way you fear them into doing so.

On the other hand, some people believe in the Disk viewpoint because they "had" experiences that collaborated such a viewpoint.

Regarding such experiences being nothing more than imagination that is triggured by what somebody like Bruce has to say about the matter, it is possible to have the viewpoint validated in a way where it seems clear that this isn't the case.

There is also the matter of Bruce having a Disk vision before reading of such a thing. Ron Kruger had an NDE where he experienced his greater self in such a way, even though he didn't read or hear about such a thing beforehand. P.M.H. Atwater and Tom Sawyer experienced their greater self in such a way during their NDEs.

I know of another man, I can't remember his name at this time, shortly after World War two he also had a vision where he found out  about things such as Oversouls without having first read or heard of such a thing.

It might've been difficult for Jesus to speak about reincarnation to the masses in a truthful way because he would've had to do so in a Disk way, and not many people in his day would be open to such a way of understanding.

Berserk2 wrote on Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:14am:
With the frequent dogmatic allusions to "the Jesus Disk,' this seems a good time to revisit the discussion of my critique of past life recall as evidence for reincarnation. 


Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #23 - Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:47pm
 
recoverer wrote on Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:45pm:
recoverer wrote on Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:42pm:
People have dogmatic viewpoints partly because they listen to what other people have to say without having any experience that collaborate such viewpoints. It is easier to get people to follow such dogma if in some way you fear them into doing so.

On the other hand, some people believe in the Disk viewpoint because they "had" experiences that collaborated such a viewpoint.

Regarding such experiences being nothing more than imagination that is triggured by what somebody like Bruce has to say about the matter, it is possible to have the viewpoint validated in a way where it seems clear that this isn't the case.

There is also the matter of Bruce having a Disk vision before reading of such a thing. Ron Kruger had an NDE where he experienced his greater self in such a way, even though he didn't read or hear about such a thing beforehand. P.M.H. Atwater and Tom Sawyer experienced their greater self in such a way during their NDEs.

I know of another man, I can't remember his name at this time, shortly after World War two he also had a vision where he found out  about things such as Oversouls without having first read or heard of such a thing.

It might've been difficult for Jesus to speak about reincarnation to the masses in a truthful way because he would've had to do so in a Disk way, and not many people in his day would be open to such a way of understanding.

I agree that information received through hypnosis isn't fully trustworthy and that some Ian Stevenson's cases might've been possession cases.

Berserk2 wrote on Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:14am:
With the frequent dogmatic allusions to "the Jesus Disk,' this seems a good time to revisit the discussion of my critique of past life recall as evidence for reincarnation. 



Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: A Critique of Alleged Past Life Recall
Reply #24 - Jan 30th, 2015 at 2:49pm
 
Please read my last post rather than the one before. The edit feature isn't working correctly.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.