DocM
|
I was touched by this NDE and encounter. I am a bit confused, because most cases of Leprosy are treated with a multi-drug regimen - so unless this story was from many decades ago, it seems a bit odd that she died of a treatable disease in modern times.
My gut feeling tells me that this was a beautiful, genuine account of a NDE and subsequent death of a person who suffered and was lifted up at the end of her earthly life.
Yet, I can take the analytic approach, or as Roger mentions question the events and story, and just to be fair, to apply equal measures to religious based NDE accounts, as to ones not associated with religion (see Mellen-Thomas Benedict's account), I will raise a few questions:
According to the account, Yolanda states to Brennan that she was spoken to by "Jesus' Father," who told her that he was going to take her to heaven. She certainly had some rudimentary knowledge of Jesus and Christianity. Had she, in years past heard the Song of Songs, at some point? Who could know that she had not (whether she could read written words or not - was she not a child once, raised by Christian parents, etc.)
Was Brennan's account accurate, or did he take poetic license as an author? (he had, at one point written about and been plagued with alcoholism, which certainly may change short term and long term memories.)?
Most accounts of NDEs are experienced by the person while clinically dead, while onlookers are completely unaware of any of the happenings on a spiritual/mental plane. Father Brennan, however, was the one who saw brilliant light surrounding Yolanda. Could he not, have been the one experiencing the NDE, along with Yolanda?
In the end, whether she quoted verbatim from the Song of Songs or did not, in no way diminishes the verification of a true NDE. Here she was, dying, and she conveyed being told by God that she was beautiful, that the winter was over and that it was time for her to shed her physical body and be accepted in heaven. I find the quotation from Song of Songs to be interesting but it really was meant more for Brennan to interpret - almost as if it were directed at him.
Many seniors, prior to dying in a nursing home or hospital are seen to have "pre-death" conversations with departed loved ones or other figures a very short time prior to death. Why do some hear from departed loved ones, while others, far fewer in number hear from God or Jesus? Perhaps they are open to it in some way. Or, perhaps their souls need this encounter to let go.
Matthew
|