Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print
Is PUL a solution to everything? (Read 8024 times)
Member unknown
Full Member
***
Offline


Gone for an undetermined
time

Posts: 132
Is PUL a solution to everything?
Oct 24th, 2008 at 5:02am
 
If you give somebody PUL, but that person does no understand how to behave better, is PUL just a fragment of the solution?

I mean, to be PUL, you should built an intention of PUL?
So you should know how to built intention.

Then you should know how to behave according to PUL.
How do you know what is right to do, through every circumstance.

Then when you built PUL, if you still got FEAR(S), the PUL is weakened.
So you should know how to deal with FEAR, which is another element.

I still do not know enough about this.

(Somehow, I know that what I really want, is you to repeat the same things (with new things) all over again untill I got it, in the depth.)

Sonia
Back to top
 

Turn your face to the sun and the shadows fall behind you. &&Maori Proverb&&&& &&
 
IP Logged
 
vajra
Ex Member


Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #1 - Oct 24th, 2008 at 7:54am
 
Smiley Hi Sonia. Thats a very big question in a few words I think. As ever how you see this depends on view. Here's one:

This world is inherently a dog eat dog and impermanent environment, and in that situation there's inherently suffering involved in life/survival. (if nothing else there's aging, illness, climate, natural threats, the need to eat other living things  and so on)

That said selfish and egotistical behaviours account (along with our typical ignorance of how to live wisely) for much of the suffering we experience - living with wisdom and compassion (through love) can eliminate much of this. Buddhism is clear that this is important in giving us the space required to see that there is a path to escape. (one by which it can be transcended)

Both Buddhism and ACIM teach that in the end we must stop reacting aggressively to what life and others seem to do to us - ACIM uses the term forgiveness, Buddhism talks about caring but not caring - equanimity. Both because by not doing so (by lashing out even if only mentally) we in effect make real the world and its nastiness in our minds. At the physical level our actions in lashing out make the reality we each experience.

This seems a lot more logical if we can accept that both what we take as ourself (our body and conscious mind) and the world are actually creations of our own mind and ultimately unreal - we project as apparently external that which we fear and dislike, so that when we lash out at it we're in effect attacking ourselves. (this is also the reason why universally loving behaviours towards all are the only way - we're in effect loving ourselves)

This however is only a part of what we're about, there's no heaven possible in this reality.

Escape from this reality requires that we awaken from the dream, that we cease to be taken in by its appearance of reality. It's in fact the work of ego, which out of fear wants us to remain separate from God/higher mind. To achieve this we must stop the above lashing out, as this gives it reality in our minds. At the physical level it creates suffering for all, and drives us deeper into the dream.

Hence the need for the forgiveness ACIM talks of - 'it never happened'.

The eventual transcendence of this reality makes possible our return to God, Heaven,  the reality where all is joy and love or whatever you call it.

Getting there is another matter, and no small task. It's in fact the work of many, many lifetimes. We have to transition from unconsciously digging ourselves deeper into the dream, to deciding there must be another way, to starting to see intellectually that love is the way, to learning what this means in practice, to using willpower to try it out and gain experience, to eventually in a wise, compassionate and skillful way deploy love as our natural unthinking response, to eventually it's becoming the only response we're capable of.

At which time we wake up, and with the dropping of our belief in this reality it falls away.

All 100% in opposition to our conditioning and the prompting of society and our instincts.

No easy task. We all get there in the end it seems, but it's not the work of an evening, and it extends far beyond simple intellectual understanding (which counts for little). We become something else (or we rediscover what we truly are and always have been) - something far greater than a frail physical body and mind in a hostile world.

The most effective means of speeding the process up seems to be self work - with the assistance of Grace/higher mind, and while following one of the spiritual paths.

Sorry not to provide a simpler answer Sonia, or to respond directly to your questions. The good news is that your seeking spiritually suggests that you are probably well on the way - it's said that it's with conscious enquiry that our progress really accelerates.

Maybe you'd consider (if you are not already) working one of the spiritual paths - it's only over time that this stuff starts to become real....
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
blink
Ex Member


Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #2 - Oct 24th, 2008 at 8:29am
 
Some people like to make it very very simple, Sonia.

What about a flower? Can you find one, put it in a vase on your table, and look at it?

What is more perfect?

If someone comes over, talk about the flower. Look at it.

If you go out, put the flower in your hair.

love, blink Smiley
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
vajra
Ex Member


Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #3 - Oct 24th, 2008 at 2:59pm
 
Many words like me, a few words like Blink - there's stuff it's tough to communicate in words Sonia.

Wink Here's references containing containing some clues, the Buddha's flower sermon is the quintessential expression of this - it gave rise to Zen which basically seeks to avoid the use of words in the transmission of spiritual teaching.

http://www.dallasmindfulness.com/zen_buddhism_taoism.htm
http://paulocoelhoblog.com/warrioroflight/06.02.2008/issue-n%C2%BA165-learning-f...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flower_Sermon

I guess it's all driving at the idea that there's an inexpressible something at work in a realised person - a person truly living through love.

We're inclined to think that loving intention, the resulting behaviours, and the courage to see them through all flow from intellectual understanding and conscious willpower.

Study, self work and commitment are certainly important while on the path, but the characteristics you describe are in the end when realised emergent and intuitive.

They arise fully formed in the person - intuitively and spontaneously from higher mind, from Spirit/Grace or whatever.

Our recent thread on the subject of theoretical vs. practical sprituality dealt with another perspective on this - the ineffectiveness of solely intellectual approaches to spirituality. It's mostly practical experience and self work that leads to emergence of the above: http://afterlife-knowledge.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.cgi?num=1223067594/0#0
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
LaffingRain
Super Member
*****
Offline


Choose this Day

Posts: 5249
Arizona
Gender: female
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #4 - Oct 26th, 2008 at 8:32pm
 
thank you Ian for all your energy in your post. I wonder why Sonia hardly ever responds?

Sonia may not be reading the replies. sorry to point this out if it offends anyone. and the good thing to notice is that maybe a view out there (I'm sure) is benefitting, even if we don't know Sonia is, and I know the reason you put your energy here is, because you give of yourself freely without expectation of return.

that's the way I like to work too. I have no expectations that Sonia will respond to anything here. I wish to be proven wrong, but don't even have an expectation on that.

you do excellent work Ian. and I love this board.
Back to top
 

... Who takes away death's sting deprives life of bitterness
WWW http://www.facebook.com/LaughingRain2  
IP Logged
 
Member unknown
Full Member
***
Offline


Gone for an undetermined
time

Posts: 132
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #5 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 4:30am
 
LaffingRain wrote on Oct 26th, 2008 at 8:32pm:
I wonder why Sonia hardly ever responds?

Sonia may not be reading the replies. sorry to point this out if it offends anyone.
.....

that's the way I like to work too. I have no expectations that Sonia will respond to anything here. I wish to be proven wrong, but don't even have an expectation on that.


Why do you wish to be proven wrong, Alysia?

What attitude do you expect from me.

If I did you or anybody wrong/hurt on this board, I'ld like to come to understanding about it, to do something about it.

But I want the change in ME to be real even if it takes me longer than what you would like.

LaffingRain wrote on Oct 26th, 2008 at 8:32pm:
and the good thing to notice is that maybe a view out there (I'm sure) is benefitting,

--> I put this sentence here, because I don't really understand it.

I just wanted to add that the things you all write on this board matter to me, but I read it and think about it and assimilate it at my own pace and I don't always feel a need/urge to add any comment to what is written.

I probably do not thank you enough for all you do here, for me and many others.

Thank you Alysia for letting me know somehow how you feel about my attitude. That too, teaches me something about how I should care, and I feel grateful for that lesson.

Sonia


Back to top
« Last Edit: Oct 27th, 2008 at 10:45am by Member unknown »  

Turn your face to the sun and the shadows fall behind you. &&Maori Proverb&&&& &&
 
IP Logged
 
hawkeye
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 886
canada
Gender: male
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #6 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 1:57pm
 
I don't think you should worry to much about answering if you don't feel you need to. What I do see.. is the possibility of a non completed communication cycle...If communication = something in the order of..the exchange of information, thoughts, or ideas, across a distance, between two or more idents... then without you answering or acknowledging it could be felt as the communication is not compleat. I know LaffingRain's ego has no need to get an answer. I think she was expressing a desire for completed communication. I have seen this many times.
Often, for instance with childern....mom...mom....mom....mom..untill finally... WHAT! All the child is really wanting is a completed communication. Acknowledgment of some sort.( I am not saying your childish!) Many time a lack of this uncompleted communication causes personality disorders. In order to receive acknowledgment when not received as a child, bad behavior can result. Its better to receive communication and acknowledgment for bad behaviour than no communication at all.(the child thought)
I wonder if PUL works the same way? If you don't receive an acknowledgment for the love you send out, do you start to open yourself to less than love, or the wrong sort of lovers/relationships in order to attempt to compleat the exchange?
anyways....
As for the PUL...have you felt it "here" yet? I know its strong "here". Although I communicate things at times that are not always appreciated, (nor appropriate for that matter) I always feel love energy here at this site. A "greater good" desire, from the participants.
Joe  
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
juditha
Ex Member


Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #7 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 2:47pm
 
Hi Sonia I  feel love is just love,you can give love out but it does no t always mean you will get it back and that hurts but you just keep giving it out because in the end you are giving the love out from inside you,if i get my feelings hurt i learnt not to show it because i would never let on because if you let on then they have won ,so just smile and cry inside like i do,it makes life a lot better.

Love and God bless  love juditha
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
hawkeye
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 886
canada
Gender: male
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #8 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 3:16pm
 
Isn't love sort of like your virginity? You don't just offer it out there for anyone to take a poke at it. To be taken and then thrown away like a dirty nose tissue. You offer it to the ones you love and care about. Those who make a positive difference in your existence. It saddens me when I read of those who don't feel love in their lives. I don't know, but perhaps their looking in the wrong place for it.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
LaffingRain
Super Member
*****
Offline


Choose this Day

Posts: 5249
Arizona
Gender: female
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #9 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 4:14pm
 
Sonia said: I just wanted to add that the things you all write on this board matter to me, but I read it and think about it and assimilate it at my own pace and I don't always feel a need/urge to add any comment to what is written.

I probably do not thank you enough for all you do here, for me and many others.

Thank you Alysia for letting me know somehow how you feel about my attitude. That too, teaches me something about how I should care, and I feel grateful for that lesson.
_____

Awhile back Sonia wanted to know all about love. the above what you just wrote has love bouncing off the words Sonia.
not the first part of your post. but what you ended up on, is a gift to me, to this board, because I am one who has been reading everything you post.
and so is Joe and Ian.

sometimes I just want a yeehaw or a go put it where the sun don't shine, anything, a comment to show you guys are not just figments of my imagination.
I'll tell you  what, my childhood taught me one thing of value to pass on: the worst offense is saying to another person, child, or animal, a non response, to not answer anything they say, or apathy. but that's my problem not yours.

I know how many hours it takes to  be on a forum, and I noticed Sonia does assimilate something, as she said she did. so I believe her.
However, it doesn't seem that you express anything that is connected to someone else's post. in what they have presented.

all of Sonia's posts are emotional appeals. I think I was looking here, on this board for more talk about Monroe's and Moen's books, and the concepts therein.
so u see it's back to my problem.

what I can do is stay in the book forum then as that is where I probably can get what I want, the stimulation I need. also I noted Ian said so much that is the same what I would say to Sonia, and two days had gone by, and no response on the ideas presented. if we are to be or develop a group growth concept, we do need to try and complete the circle of threads as best we can, like if you start a topic, I would reccommend to try and close it before starting up another one with the same exact content as the one that is not closed yet.

Joe, you show a remarkable intuitive grasp of human nature, bless you!

in conclusion, I somehow got what I wanted just now. Did you get something Sonia? I thought you did. something of an emotion, that is like PUL, perhaps a facet, the gratitude expressed is all that's needed.

I think I myself am far too long winded to stay on this board much longer however, at least on this general section.

lol. words are not enough anymore. love, alysia
Back to top
 

... Who takes away death's sting deprives life of bitterness
WWW http://www.facebook.com/LaughingRain2  
IP Logged
 
Lucy
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1158
C1
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #10 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 11:43pm
 
I also find it frustrating when new folks come and ask questions that have been asked before...multiple times...and then don't respond to the responses. The title is "Conversation Board." A conversation is a dynamic give-and-take situation. It is an interaction. Then the new person will initiate many new posts without delving in the the first post, or any other post, completely. "Drink deep or taste not..."  It is gratifying to know that the responses have mattered. I always just assume they mean something to someone.

(reminds me of a story I heard about a radio psychologist on the West Coast. She always took each question seriously and answered to the best of her ability, even though some were clearly hoaxes. When someone asked her why she did that, she said, she knew some of the questions were made up problems. But she also knew that there was someone, some where, who had that problem and was too afraid to ask, and needed to know the answer. So she answered for that person.)

Of course, the problem is, there is no easy way to search the old posts for key words that would show someone what had been written previously on that topic. You'd have to have some sort of script that could search (parse?) the old posts, and they are all connected by links. Don't know how you search through links...except the old-fashioned way...one by one.

anyway I feel both sympathy and frustration. It is difficult to come to a new board. There always seems to be a new apect to a question to explore. but it gets frustrating being here.
___________________________

PUL

I have an entiely different concept of PUL. Please it is not something you dole out! it is something you experience.  You don't give love away! That is arrogant! you experience it and invite others to experience it too.

The only place to look for PUL is inside yourself.

This is difficult because we are taught from an early age that we shoudl look "out there" for everything.

I am in love with myself. I am (standing) in love.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Lucy
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1158
C1
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #11 - Oct 27th, 2008 at 11:47pm
 
Quote:
Then you should know how to behave according to PUL.
How do you know what is right to do, through every circumstance.


What if the answer to this only exists in a non-verbal form? You can't use words to answer because the answer doesn't fit in words. And what if the answer is a process...spirit leading..you following? but no words.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Nanner
Super Member
*****
Offline


Theres only AGAPE

Posts: 764
Hamburg, Germany
Gender: female
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #12 - Oct 28th, 2008 at 4:54am
 
Member unknown wrote on Oct 24th, 2008 at 5:02am:
....
I mean, to be PUL, you should built an intention of PUL?
So you should know how to built intention.
Then you should know how to behave according to PUL.
How do you know what is right to do, through every circumstance ......
Sonia


Hi dearest Sonia,
I find the answer within the word "PUL". Pure unconditional love. When something, anything is unconditional then there shouldnt be an expectation of anything, not even for the other person to behave a certain way, in return.

I believe PUL retains the energy of massive changing on its own terms. You give it and let it go do its thing without expecting it to do anything at all.

Its sort of like planting a wee seed. Once you place it into the ground you surely hope that it grows to be that flower, but you dont really know for sure that it will. So best is: plant the seed and let it grow to be what it wants to be.

Hugs,
Nanner

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
vajra
Ex Member


Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #13 - Oct 28th, 2008 at 1:26pm
 
Nanner is repeating the essential point of my last post Sonia. Sorry if I  wasn't clear Nanner.

Loving behaviours are ultimately not a matter of intention, or of conscious knowledge. When fully integrated they are as I said emergent - the required wisdom and compassion are inherent in the person, and they just happen naturally.

I set out in my first post one possible route to this. From recognition of the need, through conscious intention to just being. This is the way those of us of a more intellectual bent can get there.

But many manage it without I suspect ever consciously intellectualising the intermediate steps as a result of life experience, and the assistance of spirit. Also without ever following a formally set out spiritual path.

We've all met those thoroughly non intellectual souls that in an almost entirely unconscious manner embody loving behaviours - it's just what they are.

Teaching and intellectual knowing are anyway in terms of the old Buddhist story only like the raft we can use to cross the river so we avoid a longer detour - no matter how useful it was at the time we must still leave it behind to get to our final destination

The destination is perhaps more radical than we at first realise - no more than per the title of Gary Renard's book 'the disappearance of the universe'.

Meaning that this universe and all its beings are the creation of collective ego. When we drop all of the beliefs it ultimately entails the entire reality collapses and we return to God. While we're still en route the result is simply a progressively less unpleasant reality....
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
identcat
Senior Member
****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 454
New Hampshire
Gender: female
Re: Is PUL a solution to everything?
Reply #14 - Oct 28th, 2008 at 1:49pm
 
[quote author=Sonia_Fielding link=1224838956/0#0 date=1224838955]If you give somebody PUL, but that person does no understand how to behave better, is PUL just a fragment of the solution?

Sonia,

Here is what I know: Say there is a child born with brain damage and all that child knows for his/her entire life is to be violent. That child had no means to comprehend the violence of his/her actions because of the brain damage received at birth. Would you deny that being PUL simply because of the physical condition that he/she agreed to when incarnating? That being may very well have been a high angel and/or an evolved spirit who chose to incarnate as a handi capped being just for that very reason as to see who is capable of extending PUL to him/her. Even if during this existance the being (or person, place or thing, animal,vegatbale or mineral)  cannot itself express PUL, it does not mean that it is with out PUL. 

Does that help clear up the question a little for you?  Much, Much love to you for a very interesting question.  cat
Back to top
 

The three things you can never take back:
The spoken word.
The unkind thought.
The misused hour.
identcat  
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.