B-dawg wrote on Jan 24th, 2007 at 1:13am:Chumley -
One other thing. About people getting what they want. People do get what they want in the end - their own selfish desires and aims or they become enthralled with the joy involved in loving others and God. Living in selfishness and opression of others will attract one to others who are into the same thing. That person will oppress and be opressed most likely, with other people, if that is what that person is after (like attracts like). God has given us free will, to use or abuse, but at some point it is enough (death). We then hang out with people who do the same or hang out with people who are after loving each other.
If there is no life review, or judgement for actions committed, then there is no morality or ethics. The world and all of its consequences become a sick joke. Kids who are raped and killed have no recompense, and there then is no justice after all for most of humanity.
*****************
If the victim(s) ceased to exist after death... why would they care?
And if the murderer ceased to exist after HE died... how
would he be able to revel in the pride of how good a killer
he was, or savor his victory over the families of the kids he
murdered... or relish the memory of how much fun it was to
kill them???
Watch out for those double-edged swords, Pratekya. They cut
both ways..!
B-man
Chumley -
If we face anihilation after death, victim and victimizer alike, then there is no ultimate justice in the universe. Because clearly there is a deficient amount of justice in this earthly life for most of humanity. In addition, your view does nothing to address the meaninglessness of life that I mentioned without the existence of God and a setting of things right after death. Life, in your view, is meaningless, temporary, brutal, and insanely unfair to most of humanity. Life is a sick joke in your view (unless you are one that victimizes others and takes pleasure in that).
Having said that, I stand by what I wrote about earlier. Its nice to think that suicide would be a way out, a way towards anihilation that one wants. We are given freedom of choice, but reponsibility for our choices comes with that. Bruce's work, near death experiences, as well as the major world religions (besides Buddhism) support that suicide is not actually a way out, and that existence continues.
I have read (I forget where now) about discarnate souls that can eventually choose annihilation, and I think this may be a possibility and don't think it conflicts with a set of core Christian beliefs. However from the reading I have done, this is somewhat rare. I don't claim to have explored these realms myself.
Lastly, you haven't addressed my arguments for the objective existence of God that I wrote about earlier. If God objectively exists (not just as a product of someone's belief system), but really exists, then what you want (anihilation after death) may not matter. You seem to think this is incredibly unfair, saying you didn't choose to be born. This may or may not be true, as some people suggest that their soul makes the choice itself to be incarnated when given the opportunity (and we don't remember this in our physical body). Life is an opportunity, and the stakes are high, but you can succeed against selfishness (as I need to) if you ask God for help. God ultimately respects your free will in every choice that you make.
Pratekya