Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
A Challenge to Brendan (Read 9684 times)
Berserk
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 979
Gender: male
A Challenge to Brendan
Dec 5th, 2006 at 7:48pm
 
[B-man:] "If you're going to try to be Christian and be a liberal
warm-fuzzy or Universal-Salvationist about it, you might as well
chuck the whole religion."
________________________
Chuck the whole religion?  Why?   Universalism does not implicitly abolish our free will.  Rather, it assumes that we are always free to make decisions to put ourselves on a loving Godward path or to refrain from doing so.  Why not explore the Godward path by direct experience before determining that you would hate it?

[B-man:] "Were I to become a Christian...,I would naturally be a CONSERVATIVE Christian. "
________________________

Of course, because you remain an intransigent secular Fundamentalist at heart.  A major problem with this mentality is its refusal to even consider that it might be mistaken and that an open-ended spiritual quest is needed.  This refusal is fueled by the fear that drives Fundamentalism.  One of the reasons why Islaimic Fundamentalists hate the West is their fear that we are striving to destroy Islam.   In fact, they sense how seductive the positive aspeccts of western culture and technology can be and project malevolent anti-Islamic intent onto us to protect themselves.  Notice how your own Fundamewntalism prompts to create an analogous fear-based warped caricature of Christianity:

[B-man:] "After all, Christianity is a blood-and-guts, kill your neighbor (unless he's meaner that you, in which case you should lick his boots) and
beat-your-wife sort of belief system.)"
_______________________________

Your fear impels you to resort to the desperate expedient of caricaturing Christianity in terms of its worst examplars who themselves refuse to apply its teachings to their lives.  Contrast your caricature with Jesus' teaching: "But I say to you who hear, love your enemies., do good to those who hate you.  Bless those who curse you.  Pray for those who mistreat you (Luke 6:27-28)."

B-man, why do you so stubbornly refuse to embark on any sort of spiritual quest by direct experience?  Forget about Christianity for a moment.   Why won't you even read a book by Bruce Moen, Robert Monroe, Emanuel Swedenborg, or a good book on NDEs?  You remind me of a guy who is up tight about the fact that he has never experienced sex or romance.  Rather than take the risk of establishing a promising relationship, he freezes like Bambi in the headlights and conjures distorted perspectives on why love and sex would not suit him.  Fear of failure lurks behind this paralysis.  Become "a player" and explore God or the afterlife by direct experience in an open-minded quest.!

[B-man:] "Now, I must say that I rather LIKE Annihilationist Christianity. It
is honest about its "God" being a killing machine who demands obedience from "his" followers."
____________________
If you wind up in a hellish state, that fate is your choice based on the just principle that like attracts like: "By your own standared or measure, it will be measured out to you (Matthew 7:2)."  It is you and your like-minded buddies who will create the hellish conditions in a realm where no thoughts can be hidden (Luke 12:2).  You will always be free to make better choices.  So why do you persist in mischaracterizing God as "a killing machine"?  Universalism and annihilationism are NOT mutually exclusive.   So you are even free to choose annihilation.

Why are you so reluctant to contemplate common elements of astral explorers with very different perspectives on the afterlife?   For example, the Bible, atheist Howard Storm's NDE, and Bruce Moen's  astral exploration all confirm both the possibility of soul retrieval and the annihilation option: e. g.

1. [Christ to Howard Storm:] "For some people this may culminate in the ultimate annihilation of their being, if after they have existed  in this eternity they still do not seek their way back to God.  For others there is the possiblity of salvation ("My Descent into Death," p. 53)."
2. [Bruce Moen:]  "Is death permanent?...Recent exploration has uncovered a sort of permanent death.  It is extremely rare."
3. The annihilation possibility in Scripture (Romans 9:22; Philippians 3:19).  The Greek "apoleia" in these texts means "annihilation."    

[B-man:] "I mean, look at Eternal Torture. Those who reject Jesus are said
to be given "what they chose" when they get thrown into "Hell". But COME ON NOW. What sane person would choose to be tortured forever?"
____________________________________________________

So when are you going to try "sane" choices.  If postmortem torture is your fate, the suffering will result from your gravitation towards like-minded souls to avoid the company of the loving souls you dismiss as boring goodie-two shoes.
As Swodenborg learns during his astral exploration,  the hellbound initially love their new residence.  Only gradually does this realm become hellaceous.  But theirs is merely an educational voyage of self-discovery of the practical outcome of their own preferences and self-chosen nature.  These souls are not eternally trapped; they can make new choices and be retrieved.

[B-man:]What about those people (like myself) who would NEVER be happy in
"Heaven", short of being subjected to a radical pre-frontal lobotomy?...The Christians would get what THEY chose (a Christian afterlife. Hope they like singing and gardening!)...The afterlife is full of rules and regulations I can't stomach? No problem, I don't have to go there - and I won't be punished for that choice!
__________

The "rules and regulations" will merely be a function of the prevailing atmosphere of pure unconditional love [PUL], not of stifling legalism.  How can you pre-judge such a blissful state of elevated consciousness that you have never even experienced?  Your secular Fundamentalism lurks behind your comments here.   You are terrified that if you began a legitmate spiritual quest, your old self might be replaced by a more spiritual self.  You would rather be miserable and empty than admit that you just might be wrong.  

[B-man:] "According to Christianity, "God"/Jesus explicitly demands "my way or the highway", right?"
__________________

Wrong!  Consider just 5 New Testament texts that teach the possibility of salvation apart from formal profession of Faith in Christ:
(1) "John said to Him, `Teacher, we saw a man using your name to cast out demons, but we told him to stop because he isn't one of our group.' `Don't stop him!' Jesus said.  `No one who peforms miraclews in my name will soon be able to speak evil of me.'  Anyone who is not against us is for us (Mark 9:38-40).'"
If Jesus' attitude were "my way or the highway" as you suggest, why doesn't he summon this Jewish exorcist for indoctrination?

(2) "Blessed are the poor in Spirit (i.e. the truly humble) ; for theirs is the kingdom of heaven (Matthew 5:3)."
(3) "There will be eternal life for those [non-Christians] who by perseverance in dooiing good seek for glory and honor and immortality (Romans 2:7).
(4) "Sin is not imputed where there is no moral' law (Romans 5:15)."
(5) "God has overlooked the times of ignorance (prior to Christ's arrival--so Paul in Acts 17:30)."

Such texts are consistent with Jesus' reply to atheist Howard Storm during his NDE: "[Storm:] What is thebest religion?  I was expecting the answer to be something like Methodist or Presbyterian or Catholic, or some other denomination. They answered, `The religion that brings you closest to God.'"

Don
Back to top
« Last Edit: Dec 6th, 2006 at 4:44pm by Berserk »  
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #1 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 8:04pm
 
This is kind of off the subject,

I read Howard Storm's book recently, and I like most of what it says.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Ra.
New Member
*
Offline



Posts: 42
Montclair, New Jersey
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #2 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 8:31pm
 
You do realize your going by a book right? Everything you "think" jesus said you have gotten from the bible.

Jesus was a regular guy, if he was born in this day an age he would be considered to be someone like Gandi. It is a shame that he had to be born in a time where people attributed everything to acts of god.

The people that wrote the bible needed someone that lived so people could relate to him somehow. Who better to use then Modern day Gandi. You seem to forget that it was pretty much the Religious community at the time that put Jesus to death.

Another thing though somewhat irrelevant, everytime I speak to a pastor or another religious figure and question him about his beliefs they can't hold an argument. They always run back to the bible for help. Basically they just quote the bible. By quoting the bible they are just proving that they get all there "info" from a book.

Kinda disgusting in my opinion.

What i'm trying to say even though you probally know from my previous words is this.
I believe that your religion is bull, I believe they are all bull.

What do you think about Zeus, Apollo, Aphrodite, Dionysus and the rest of the greek pantheon?

How about Anubis, Bast, Nephthys, Osiris and certain other Deitys from Egyptian mythology?

We consider this myth now.
We say that these Diety's NEVER existed.

Myth: A traditional, typically ancient story dealing with supernatural beings, ancestors, or heroes that serves as a fundamental type in the worldview of a people, as by explaining aspects of the natural world or delineating the psychology, customs, or ideals of society.

We call this myth now. But in that time it was Religion, people would die for these gods, kill for these gods, and had books that in their minds proved the existence of these gods.

See a connection yet?

Every continent had a different religion.

Get it yet? I hope so.

I have seen the effects that NDE's have had on atheists and believers alike.
I have read documented reports on OBE's that blow me away. From skeptical polymaths like myself.
I have spent countless hours researching and reading about the afterlife, Critiquing and learning at the same time.

I believe in the afterlife because I have proof, I have knowledge, Real knowledge, not knowledge from a 2000 year old book that talks of things most commonly found in fairy tales.

Religion spits in the face of science on every page.
Stop quoting scriptures and wake up.

As to the others on this board who have come to know the REAL GOD.
KUDOS TO YOU.



Back to top
 

Spiritualism is the acceptance of empirically elicited evidence that the human consciousness survives physical death and that those who survive can communicate with those who are physically on earth in a number of ways.
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #3 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 8:46pm
 
Ra.

I don't believe that everything the Bible says is true or represents the word of God.

However, I do believe that Jesus was/is more than just a regular guy. I've had experiences and received spirit messages stating that he is a significant part of the spiritual evolution of mankind. It is mistake to underestimate him because of how some fundamentalists have misrepresented him.

Going by what I've been told, his help is available to anybody who reaches out to him.  Of course when a person asks for help, such a person needs to have faith that he or she will receive the kind of help that is needed.




Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
I Am Dude
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 1462
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #4 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 9:00pm
 
Quote:
[B-man:] "If you're going to try to be Christian and be a liberal
warm-fuzzy or Universal-Salvationist about it, you might as well
chuck the whole religion."


All religions need to be chucked. They hold us back from discovering the truth of what we really are and limit our true potential.  Why do you think so many people are caught in the lower focus levels of their hollow heavens and hells. Religion. If we accept that going to heaven to be with god and jesus is all there is for us after this life on earth, we end our quest for the truth and can never unlock our full potential.
Back to top
 

But seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things will be added unto you.
 
IP Logged
 
Tim F.
Ex Member


Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #5 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 9:12pm
 
Don created this thread out of the spirit of debate; not of judgement.

What is the spirit in which you reading this have replied?

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 979
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #6 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 9:32pm
 
[Ra:] "You do realize your going by a book right?"
___________________________________________
Actually no.  I go by my own many paranormal experiences of the supernatural that support the Christian faith.   B-man made claims about a book which warrant responses from that book.  I hate to break this to you, Ra, but most of our knowledge comes from research and experiences reported in books.    

[Ra:] "You seem to forget that it was pretty much the Religious community at the time that put Jesus to death."
____________________________

How typical of New Age hubris to make insulting assumptions about people they don't know!  I have a Harvard doctorate in biblical history.  What are your qualifications for your pompous insults?

[Ra:] "Another thing though somewhat irrelevant, everytime I speak to a pastor or another religious figure and question him about his beliefs they can't hold an argument. They always run back to the bible for help....Kinda disgusting in my opinion."
________

How amusingly arrogant!  I am far more knowledgeable than you in both religion and the evidence for an afterlife and could crush you in any in depth debate.  Care to engage?  You substitute profanity-laced insults for rigorous analysis of the real issues.  In your posts, you get away with this (despite my protest the Poer Moderator) bccause this site has the expected New Age bias and only makes a pretense at maintaining a modicum of civil dialogue.  I have been absent for several months and will soon leave the site again, until another post catches my fancy.   I am amused by the fact that my courteous posts invariably last only a day or do before being pummeled by unchecked insults that violate the site's unreinforced guidlines.

[Ra:] "I believe that your religion is bull, I believe they are all bull."
_________________________________________________________
Your vulgar dismissals only masks your historical and biblical illiteracy.  How do you counter the eyewitness biblical testimony of miracles such as Jesus' resurrection appearances?  The answer is that you don't even know what the grounds for these eyewitness connections are.


[Ra:] "I believe in the afterlife because I have proof, I have knowledge, Real knowledge, not knowledge from a 2000 year old book that talks of things most commonly found in fairy tales."
____________________________

Proof?  You merely have a premature New Age doctrinal system based on flawed and insconsistent inferences drawn from inspiring, but evidentially flawed reports of paranormal experiences.  Over the years, I have demonstrated this here in many threads on afterlife evidence drawn from astral projection,  OBEs, NDEs, and channeling.   I believe in some of these paranormal reports, but none of them amount to anything close to proof.

[Ra:] "Stop quoting scriptures and wake up."
______________________________________

B-man made several misguided claims about historic Christianity that invited a response from Scripture.   If you can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen.
It is you who are "asleep" the incredible variety of experiences, ancient and modern, that support the claims of historic Christianity.  

Don





Back to top
« Last Edit: Dec 6th, 2006 at 12:11am by Berserk »  
 
IP Logged
 
DocM
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 2168
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #7 - Dec 5th, 2006 at 11:37pm
 
I am in complete agreement with Don's last comments.   Ra, it is inappropriate for you to call another's religion "bull."  Stating opinion is one thing, but your comments violate some rules of this forum.  I suggest that you voluntarily remove them before the peer moderator system is invoked.

Don - your presence on the board has been missed.  Many times and in several conversations I had hoped to see you chime in with an interesting comment.  However, I must say, that the title for this thread "Re: A challange to Brendan," invites a move in and of itself to the Off Topics forum.  Truly the thread could have been entitled: "Evidence in support of spiritual Christianity."  Although I am Jewish, I believe that the teachings of Jesus are absolutely in line with living a loving life and advancing one's spiritual quest.  You are correct in stating that some will cite the worst examples out of context from the bible or from history to support the "blood and guts" version of christianity - this shows a poor understanding of the overall message.


Matthew
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
augoeideian
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 958
South Africa
Gender: female
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #8 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 5:10am
 
Don, thank you for your wisdom.  And Tim yes what Spirit is this read in - so true.
The Etheric Christ Consciousness is a jewel from God's Throne.  

PUL
Back to top
 

&&
 
IP Logged
 
Tim F.
Ex Member


Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #9 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 12:19pm
 
If a friend was on their death bed, you probably wouldn't try to insult them out of their
belief system about the after-life. It would be completely natural to connect with them out of  an open heart. You'd recognise what you have in common with them, not what is different.
We all die. We all want to be happy. Those are things that everyone on this thread share in common.

We carry different belief systems. Matthew is jewish. Don is christian. I'm a buddhist. I believe truth is truth and that metaphysical or religious belief can be a vehicle towards it or a cage shutting one off from it.
I don't feel that the divine resides in a hierarchical power structure or one particular book but rather is everywhere all-at-once. Wholeness doesn't exist just in one place, it exists all of one piece.

Anyone that's found this site is probably interested more in expanding and sharing experience than attacking or defending belief.

My personal view is Jesus is a Master of Wisdom. My feeling is there are many. Some are known by name and some aren't. Each of us get to travel the path in our own ways. The wonderful thing is no matter how different we seem to each other, we're all in this together.

That makes my heart sing, knowing we're all here.

(these are my morning thoughts. To all of you: make a great day!)

Love, Tim

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Ra.
New Member
*
Offline



Posts: 42
Montclair, New Jersey
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #10 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 2:20pm
 
Bro your entitled to your beliefs.

I could care less about your "Harvard" credentials.
I have a trained photographic memory, school is based on memory and analysis.

As to your talk of biblical texts being confirmed by history your wrong.
It is confirmed by the bible.

Get off your knees friend. I am a much more polite person in general but when it comes to religion I think I am doing you a courtesy by being blunt.

In all honesty it doesn't matter; you'll know the truth when you die.

O one more thing. Kudos to you for wasting 6 years in college studying religion so you could tell off non-believers like me Cheesy

I'm going to stop posting on this forum as of today, Looks like most of the people here are the very same I am trying to get away from in society.
Back to top
 

Spiritualism is the acceptance of empirically elicited evidence that the human consciousness survives physical death and that those who survive can communicate with those who are physically on earth in a number of ways.
 
IP Logged
 
Ra.
New Member
*
Offline



Posts: 42
Montclair, New Jersey
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #11 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 2:26pm
 
O one last post.

I agree with Tim.F on jesus being a Master of Wisdom.

I gots lots o love fo jesus Smiley Smiley Smiley

lotsa disdain for religion  Smiley Smiley Smiley

Hope you guys found my posts amusing.
Hopefully I'll talk to you in the next life PEACE  Cry

Back to top
 

Spiritualism is the acceptance of empirically elicited evidence that the human consciousness survives physical death and that those who survive can communicate with those who are physically on earth in a number of ways.
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 979
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #12 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 5:13pm
 
Ra,

Leaving today, huh?  So when your vapid arrogance is directly challenged, you cut and run, thus demonstrating your inability to season your penchant for blustering tirades with a pinch of intellectual rigor.  You resort to ad hominem attacks, F-bombs, and other obscenities to mask your limited capabilities.  With your alleged photographic memory, I'd expect a man like you to relish my challenge that you back up your claim that research on NDEs and OBEs PROVES the existence of an afterlife.   You have clamed that no pastor can stand up to you in a debate and I have called your bluff and exposed you as biblically and historically illiterate.  You made claims about the Bible that you cannot begin to back up.  You have read none of the standard scholarly works in the field.   In short, you don't know enough to be intellectually entitled to aN opinion.  So you understandably choose to go whimpering home to Momma rather than embrace my challenge and defend your unwarranted claims.

I eagerly await your "proof' thread.
Don

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
B-dawg
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 596
Missoula, Montana
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #13 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 6:28pm
 
Ra,

Leaving today, huh?  So when your vapid arrogance is directly challenged, you cut and run, thus demonstrating your inability to season your penchant for blustering tirades with a pinch of intellectual rigor.  You resort to ad hominem attacks, F-bombs, and other obscenities to mask your limited capabilities.  With your alleged photographic memory, I'd expect a man like you to relish my challenge that you back up your claim that research on NDEs and OBEs PROVES the existence of an afterlife.   You have clamed that no pastor can stand up to you in a debate and I have called your bluff and exposed you as biblically and historically illiterate.  You made claims about the Bible that you cannot begin to back up.  You have read none of the standard scholarly works in the field.   In short, you don't know enough to be intellectually entitled to aN opinion.  So you understandably choose to go whimpering home to Momma rather than embrace my challenge and defend your unwarranted claims.

I eagerly await your "proof' thread.
Don
*****************
Cool it, Don.
You must admit, your style is calculated to bring out the beast in people.
So why use terms like "go whimpering home to momma?" (That's how you got Spit so mad he threatened you physically - counterproductive to say the least.)
I'll take up your challenge later. I've got a few things to say. PM okay with you?

B-man
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 979
Gender: male
Re: A Challenge to Brendan
Reply #14 - Dec 6th, 2006 at 7:06pm
 
Yes, Brendan,  but Spitfire proved to be a truthseeker after all.  The higher temperatures inspired him to rise to the challenge.  He began to share his deepest questions and we had a protracted and rewarding dialogue, the best I've ever had on this site.  We are now buddies!

Why won't you read and react to even one book on the afterlife as a basis for dialogue?  Then the game would be transformed from polemic to fellow seekers trying to find hope through evidence of postmortem survival.   Are you willing to admit that you are even open to a spiritual quest, Christian or otherwise?  If so, how are you pursuing such a quest?  If I could be convinced that you had a sincere desire to know, I would be excruciatingly polite in all my communications with you.

Don

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.