spooky2
|
I've seen a documentation on tv where someone was in surgery and they had wired the patient's head; it was for a relatively long period inactive, a flat line, and they mentioned it was not only some peripheric measurement, the whole brain was inactive; they continued surgery as the rest of the body functions were stable, and they brought him/her (can't remember the gender) back, and this patient told them after it what they did when he/she was "out". That would be a proof that the brain is not the only thing which produces memories/perception, if it was only witnessed by some hundreds judges and policemen and professional magic tricksters...
Technically B-man it doesn't work, as Matthew said, you need to rebuild the exact cell network for this. Impossible.
Philosphically, I'm with Dave, I like to add that there is a categorial difference in "experience" and it's codification/mirroring in brain structures. It's just not the same; we have a correlation in brain damage and functionality of mind in the physical, no brain no human, that's clear, but that doesn't mean there is causality. If you see the flash of a lightning and you're hearing always thunder, then scientists don't claim that this light and this sound is the same identical thing, why do they do it with brain and experience/thoughts ?
Spooky
|