Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
Reincarnation & population increase (Read 7824 times)
your_mum
New Member
*
Offline


POWER TO THE PEOPLE!

Posts: 39
UK
Gender: male
Reincarnation & population increase
Mar 31st, 2006 at 6:55pm
 
just wondering.... how can the reincarnation theory be true if the population of the earth is constantly increasing- i probably look like a narrow-minded simpleton for asking this and theres probably a really obvious answer, but ah well....
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Spitfire
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #1 - Mar 31st, 2006 at 7:03pm
 
I would be suprised, if anyone had the answer to this question. it's one of those questions, which really cast doubt upon the existance of the afterlife.

You could think of it this way though,

we are all people/things in another dimension playing a video game, a few people first discover the game...aka being human... soon they spread the word that theres a new game thats fun to play, soon theres a huge waiting list... those who do well during a life, get a bonus life... and those who do bad get sent to the back of the queue...

since, we dont know how many spirit beings there are in existance, in different dimensions.... planets were ever, we have no idea, how many are on the waiting list.

it's like a game of poker, you spend your time perfecting it... you will often be given a spot at the big events... do well at being human and get a free bonus go, i guess.

ultimately... to keep existing, the nature of existance will be totally beyond our graps at the moment.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Cricket
Senior Member
****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 351
Gender: female
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #2 - Mar 31st, 2006 at 7:29pm
 
I've never understood how earth population was relevant to reincarnation.  There are so many scenarios that make sense with any earth population from ten thousand to ten times what we have now that I just see it as a non issue.

All souls could have existed forever, and just "cycle" differently, or some waited to come to earth until more were needed.  New souls could be "born" (or maybe split, like ameboe, leaving two or more souls with the same memories before the split but different as they go on afterward).  Souls could be spread amongst various world, more and more coming to earth as our population increases.  There are probably other possibilities that I haven't thought of, but even leaving out the "fancy" stuff, the simple expeidient of shorting the between-lives period from (as an example) a hundred thousand years to ten years (okay, extreme, but it's an example ;>) would take care of a lot of it!
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
dave_a_mbs
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 1655
central california
Gender: male
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #3 - Apr 1st, 2006 at 4:24pm
 
This is a non-trivial question, and one that has caused a very large controversy. I do past life work and have reports from those with whom I work, as well as personal memories. As far as I can tell, the question is a good one, but it implies the wrong answer, since it pulls for remarks that justify individual human existence right here on this planet. That doesn't seem to be the way it actually works.

From the view of past life reports, we begin as little more than a twist of emptiness around more emptiness, a momentary dream image flitting through the Mind of God, and then progress through a succession of stages, and often through a succession of environments in this, and other, worlds.  Most of the process is recoverable through deep regression.

I personally recall a brief moment of life as a worm - one of those ocean bottom slime suckers, I suspect. It was great, just what a worm wanted.  This was followed by what seems to have been millions of incarnations as various kinds of lower life forms, higher life forms, a huge number of incarnations as some kind of ape-like shaggy things, then as assorted people, none of whom were significant, and finally as who and what I am today.

From our position here, as members of this life, we have the opportunity to understand and emotionally participate in the growth process on a wider basis, so that we can go on through merger with our ultimate spiritual nature (Ramana Maharshi worked in this area with his yoga) through meditation, good living, good works etc, so that we reach transcendental experiences like samadhi, and then our awareness returns to God, bringing with it all our experiences of living.

This is often called "enlightenment", although the term is rarely used in a precise manner. The Hari Krishna movement championed by Swami Prabhavananda (sp?) was directed at "back to Godhead", and the antics of its members were actually superficial to that purpose. The goal was to lose the ego in meditation and return to the ego-less state in which we are one with the Ultimate Self.

When viewed abstractly, the entire cycle of lives appears to be a major flux of  soul stuff, carrying individual information, much like our own sensory processes extend our interests into the world, sense and recover facts by adopting the proper personality construct for the moment, whether as a student studying, a householder arranging affairs, a yogi in meditation, or whatever we happen to be doing. Then our sensory processes interpret and return these facts to the mind where they are integrated into the wholeness of our being, perhaps leading to new studies, affairs or meditations.

Through this feedback process, God continues to create, evolve and extend Its nature. It seems that God is made of information, entropy, that perpetually expends as the creative activity occurs. (I got a PhD by demonstrating how these processes operate in everyday life. It's a simple, but messy mathematical progression called iterated complexions.) Conversely, we who are making the cycle become what Edgar Cayce called "Co-creators with God" - as we merge back into the Oneness, and at the same time, we retain our personal self.  Then the cycle seems to go around again - as of each of us is a "God-Seed"  that is being nurtured and is growing.

The flow of soul material thus emanates at the center of reality as manifestations of God, expands through sundry lives, only to return to God with new information that expands the nature of God. Since everything is ultimately God-in-action, there is no paradox here. There is a nearly endless supply of worlds, soul-stuff, and an infinite future in which to evolve. Our evolution is actually the evolution of God as God enjoys Itself. (The Sanskrit term for this is lila, meaning play.) It is only our limited perception that seems to limit everything to being isolated individuals with few or no commonalities.  In fact, you are God, and you just think of yourself as a limited individual because you probably never thought about yourself from this perspective.

I salute the God in you and I salute you as God-made-manifest!

dave
Back to top
 

life is too short to drink sour wine
WWW  
IP Logged
 
Bud_S
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #4 - Apr 2nd, 2006 at 11:16am
 
Trying to reconcile souls with population is like trying to reconcile the volume of raindrops in the ocean.  You'll probably never figure it out, and it doesn't change the fact that there exists both drops and ocean in constant flux.  The afterlife is not an accounting  problem, imho.  Whenever a complicated question like this arises that spawns many complicated answers, it's probably the wrong question and much simpler than we have made it.  No self sustaining system that works well is ever that complicated.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
your_mum
New Member
*
Offline


POWER TO THE PEOPLE!

Posts: 39
UK
Gender: male
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #5 - Apr 2nd, 2006 at 2:36pm
 
ok thanks very much guys, was just something i wanted to get out of the way. i've just realised how painfully narrow-minded i am- i would never even have dreamt of perceptions like that. cheers Smiley
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Jambo
Full Member
***
Offline


1987, a great year for
the human race.

Posts: 182
UK
Gender: male
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #6 - Apr 2nd, 2006 at 3:06pm
 
Quote:
Trying to reconcile souls with population is like trying to reconcile the volume of raindrops in the ocean.  You'll probably never figure it out, and it doesn't change the fact that there exists both drops and ocean in constant flux.  The afterlife is not an accounting  problem, imho.  Whenever a complicated question like this arises that spawns many complicated answers, it's probably the wrong question and much simpler than we have made it.  No self sustaining system that works well is ever that complicated.


Brilliant point Bud Smiley

Dave the evidence that u put across contradicts what some spiritualists say about reincarnation between species of animals, e.g. dog living as a human next?
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 979
Gender: male
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #7 - Apr 2nd, 2006 at 3:52pm
 
Your Mum,

You have posed an excellent question, one that exposes a devastating flaw in conventional New Age reincarnationism.   This flaw forces New Agers to resort to the desperate expedient of alleging prior lives as aliens or lower life forms like earth worms.  Such attempts derive no significant support from so-called spontaneous past life recall and nudge reincarnationism in the direction of being unfalsifiable even in principle and therefore meaningless.   Hypnotic regression cannot really count as evidence of prior lives as earthworms because of the proven hypnotic distortion of memories and because of the mutiplicity of Napoleons who show up in large-group past life regressions.  Reputable past life readers have been discredited in a study which demonstrated their inability to come up with the same IMMEDIATE past life for the same individuals.  And of course, New Agers relentlessly ignore Swedenborg's demonstration that alleged cases of past life recall are in fact illusions created by "spirit bonding" in which the contactee confuses the spirit's memories with his own.  

At the same time, humans seem to have the latent abiilty to tune in the lives of lower life forms.  During atheist Howard Storm's NDE, "Jesus and the angels" provide him a glimpse of a future 200 years from now in which "everybody was a student of Nature, which they knew intimately, and with which they could communicate, KNOWING THE SENSATIONS AND VIBRATION OF EVERY PART OF CREATION ("My Descent into Death," p. 46)."

Of course, the population explosion poses no serious problem for Howard Storm's NDE insight that A FEW actually might reincarnate or for the minority of reincarnationists who insist that new souls are constantly being created who have no prior past life history.    

Don

Back to top
« Last Edit: Apr 2nd, 2006 at 10:44pm by Berserk »  
 
IP Logged
 
Touching Souls
Super Member
*****
Offline


LOVE IS ALL, SHINE YOUR
LIGHT THAT OTHERS MAY
SEE

Posts: 1966
Metaline Falls, WA
Gender: female
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #8 - Apr 2nd, 2006 at 4:00pm
 
Your Mum,

Not everyone reincarnates on Earth. There are an infinite number of planets, universes, galaxies, dimensions where souls can continue their advancement.  Then there are those from these other planets, universes, galaxies, dimensions, etc. who do reincarnate on Earth for the lessons to be learned here.  It's not all black and white as some would have you think. Open up your mind to all the possibilities for that is what all this is, unlimited possibilities. Wink

Love, Mairlyn Wink
Back to top
 

I AM THAT I AM -- WE ARE ALL ONE -- TOUCHING SOULS
Wink
WWW minniecricket2000  
IP Logged
 
Rondele
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #9 - Apr 2nd, 2006 at 6:26pm
 
Don-

Do you know of any research linking memories to  DNA?

If that's theoretically possible, it would perhaps offer an alternative explanation for reincarnation.

If we can inherit talents, why not memories of our ancestors as well?  Or at least those memories that caused strong psychic imprints.  It might explain why some of us have powerfully strong fears or attractions that are not otherwise accounted for in our own lives.

Roger
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
recoverer
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 5027
Gender: male
Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #10 - Apr 3rd, 2006 at 11:46am
 
Do people really believe they can figure out the mathematics while down here? I believe you have to be on the other side before you can figure out the numbers game. There are certain variables we don't know about while in the physical. And it doesn't matter how good you are at Algebra.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Spitfire
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #11 - Apr 3rd, 2006 at 1:00pm
 
Quote:
Do people really believe they can figure out the mathematics while down here? I believe you have to be on the other side before you can figure out the numbers game. There are certain variables we don't know about while in the physical. And it doesn't matter how good you are at Algebra.


It's only a matter of time... before you can calculate the number, the only thing thats not certain is how long, and by who.

The whole number's game.. is based upon the need for us, to think were special.. and immortal though. Nobody wants to think, new spirits are being produced all the time... and we are but 1 drop of a vast ocean. An ocean, thats ever increasing..

Just does'nt give one a sense of purpose, and ones life meaning... Especially when most dont wish to be included into a union with everyone in the world, as we all have our own values... and they are in constant conflict.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Bud_S
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #12 - Apr 3rd, 2006 at 2:21pm
 
Quote:
Just does'nt give one a sense of purpose, and ones life meaning... Especially when most dont wish to be included into a union with everyone in the world, as we all have our own values... and they are in constant conflict.


Whether we wish for it or not, it's a irrefutable fact that we already are in a  union with everyone else.  Take DNA.  We all originated from the same place in the physical world, whether you believe in Adam/Eve or evolution or almost any other origin except for maybe the alien/monkey theory (though it must have been a small troup of lady monkeys).  I'm not trying to be clever, but demonstrate a kind of union we already have.  It's not a huge leap for me to expect that since we are already in union and connected, that we are this way in any other form of our existance.  It doesn't make sense to me scientifically that we would have absolute biological connection with all our fellow beings, and be absolutely separate in spirit.  It makes more sense to me that our current physical form would reflect our past physical AND non-physical transitions.   There must be a fabric of connectedness between us on all levels to varying degrees, our latest biological form being just the most recent physical example and a result of all that preceded us physically and non-physically.  IMHO, my ego hopes the afterlife connectedness doesn't assimilate the raindrops completely, but allows them to drift around separately for a while.  With such connectedness though, I think whether on a disk level or "all that is" level, we end up blurred with everyone else eventually.  Jst my opinion.

As for sense of purpose, I think we confuse this with ego.  Well, I certainly do anyway.  It's hard for me to admit I don't have a grand purpose sometimes.  Really, sometimes I think my purpose is to ultimately understand I don't have any special purpose other than to grow, change, and try to have a good time - things that pretty much happen no matter what path one is on.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Spitfire
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #13 - Apr 3rd, 2006 at 2:33pm
 
Quote:
Whether we wish for it or not, it's a irrefutable fact that we already are in a  union with everyone else.  Take DNA.  We all originated from the same place in the physical world, whether you believe in Adam/Eve or evolution or almost any other origin except for maybe the alien/monkey theory (though it must have been a small troup of lady monkeys).  I'm not trying to be clever, but demonstrate a kind of union we already have.  It's not a huge leap for me to expect that since we are already in union and connected, that we are this way in any other form of our existance.  It doesn't make sense to me scientifically that we would have absolute biological connection with all our fellow beings, and be absolutely separate in spirit.  It makes more sense to me that our current physical form would reflect our past physical AND non-physical transitions.   There must be a fabric of connectedness between us on all levels to varying degrees, our latest biological form being just the most recent physical example and a result of all that preceded us physically and non-physically.  IMHO, my ego hopes the afterlife connectedness doesn't assimilate the raindrops completely, but allows them to drift around separately for a while.  With such connectedness though, I think whether on a disk level or "all that is" level, we end up blurred with everyone else eventually.  Jst my opinion.

As for sense of purpose, I think we confuse this with ego.  Well, I certainly do anyway.  It's hard for me to admit I don't have a grand purpose sometimes.  Really, sometimes I think my purpose is to ultimately understand I don't have any special purpose other than to grow, change, and try to have a good time - things that pretty much happen no matter what path one is on.


I dont think it's that kind of connectedness, not the 'am i biologically the same as the next 2 legged human'. It's when people say... we are all part of the same body/consciousness... etc.

I would'nt like to be connected to certain groups of people.. and vice versa... because our minds disagree with each others actions/thoughts/beliefs.

Purpose... ego... does'nt really matter what you call it, you need to feel needed - you need a purpose... you need to believe we live for a reason, it's just part of human nature. Wether this is the same when we return to the dirt or the spiritual realms.. is another question totally. But as humans, theres hate.. and other emotions which we have learned through experience... which just makes the concept of 'oneness' unattractive.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Bud_S
Ex Member


Re: Reincarnation & population increase
Reply #14 - Apr 3rd, 2006 at 3:22pm
 
Quote:
I dont think it's that kind of connectedness, not the 'am i biologically the same as the next 2 legged human'. It's when people say... we are all part of the same body/consciousness... etc.


I understand and I posed an argument why it made sense to me.  Can you tell me why we would be biologically intertwined but not otherwise? 

Quote:
I would'nt like to be connected to certain groups of people.. and vice versa... because our minds disagree with each others actions/thoughts/beliefs.


Well, me neither, but like I said, I believe you (we) don't have a choice - we're all quite connected.  If you become disconnected, it will be your illusion, not everyone else's.  (imho)

Quote:
Purpose... ego... does'nt really matter what you call it, you need to feel needed - you need a purpose... you need to believe we live for a reason, it's just part of human nature. Wether this is the same when we return to the dirt or the spiritual realms.. is another question totally. But as humans, theres hate.. and other emotions which we have learned through experience... which just makes the concept of 'oneness' unattractive.


Ever study Buddism?  I have only read a little bit.  I think the lifelong pursuit of nirvana deeply involves our understanding of our ego and our place and how it relates to oneness.  Might be worth a look.  I need to read more about it.... seems to me the last time I did, the idea of oneness wasn't attractive to me either. Undecided  And I'm not debating it because the idea is attractive to me, it's not,  it just seems to be the most logical to me given what we can observe. 

I don't necessarily think oneness is instant and automatic, I think we spend a good deal of time experiencing things with a distinct awareness of our identity.  The thing that nags at the back of my mind is A) everything that has a beginning has an end, and B) in the beginning, we were one vast expanse of possibility - key word "one."
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.