Quote:My two cents, SF,
"Why would an omnipotent being require worship?"
See, I think it is more complicated than that. If we all contain a "god spark," inside us, in some ways, a supreme being which we are part of (whether we recognize it or not) commanding us to worship him, is in effect telling ourselves to aspire to our higher and more noble nature and aspirations. However, understanding does not come quickly (it hasn't for me). So initially, it makes sense to live by the golden rule, follow the ten commandments to live together and then, as realization of our true nature comes out, ascend to a higher plane.
"God cannot be omnipotent for he cannot make a stone which he cannot lift." C'mon Spity, that is a really dumb one. The notion of God is beyond a physical superman with a long flowing beard. You are using your own definitions about a being that none of us can completely comprehend.
#6 "God has to be evil aswell as good, as he punish's man for not living by his rules, therefore nullfying free will. " No, free will is there, or else man would not be able to choose right or wrong action (what Kyo calls cosmoethical action). God does not punish in reality, as our bad actions with ill intent cause our own bad realities to manifest (you reap what you sow in the world).
I could give my take on all of them, but that is enough for now. The bible containing contradictions is understandable, as God was not dictating every word. The message and understanding is what is important, no matter what evangelist preachers say.
And as far as earthly and divine "evils, and sufferings," many on this board feel that through suffering and acceptance, eventually we reach higher ideals as we overcome obstacles. Many of these are random, and it does not seem fair, but it simply is. Acceptance of what is, is a lesson many of us take a long time to learn.
Matthew
Evening matt,
Im only trying to prove, the christian god does not exist - any other type of god, interpretation of god, could be plausable depending upon it's characteristics.
Personally, i think we are all probley just a part of another being, the earth is the cell - the universe the body, and the more humans that come into existance is like the brain creating neuron connections through learning, the more humans the smarter we become.
With my "god cannot make a stone he cannot lift" was to prove theres no such thing as an all powerful being, aka omnipotentancey.
let me ask you, how do you know whats right from wrong? if you were 5 years of age and someone else stuck a gun in your hand, would you fully comprehend the consequences of pulling the trigger? do you deserve to be shot in return because you killed someone because you had a power in your hands you did not understand? If god created us, and is all powerful, and can see the past, present and future, he wanted that kid to shoot someone, for he did not interfear, thus god stood by and let an evil deed take place, thus meaning he condones what we consider evil actions.
I can understand, learning lessons, i do not get pain which is pointless, you can learn what cancers like by living with it for 10 minutes, instead of dying slowley over a few months, which means god [if he exists] wants you to suffer needlessley, unless he/it does'nt exist, and then it just comes down to 80% shit luck.
If you accept things which happen in your life, your destined to live a life of pain. If you fight with conviction and dedication to change your deck of cards, eventually you shall be rewarded, and if you ar'nt at least you have pride, which is somthing that lasts a lifetime.