B-dawg
Super Member
   
Offline

Afterlife Knowledge Member
Posts: 596
Missoula, Montana
Gender:
|
Don, you said...
(1) In the Old Testament God often expresses regret for what He and others have done. How can you regret something for which you yourself are responsible? The nature of divine omniscience is a mystery which cannot simply be reduced to a Greek conception. ***************** Expresses regret? But "He" is omniscient, no? How can any entity express regret for past (mis)deeds unless they did not know what the future held when they committed said (mis)deeds? You are postulating a LIMITED "God" here, Don.
(4) As for God transcending time, the Bible never actually makes this claim, though you might claim it is implicit. In any case, divine foreknowledge precedes any sense of predestination, not vice versa (see Romans 8:29). In other words, God foreknows what we will do with our free will and fits this into His plan. But this does not mean that He always approves of our decisions. We remain free to make a mess of our world if we so choose. ***************** If "He" knew what we would do with our free will prior to creating us, and then went ahead and created us, that is as good as predestination. You cannot deny, that to maintain this line of reasoning is to say that humans are pre-programmed robots following a scenario which originated in the mind of "God." So much for free will... Or do you mean to say, that we can SURPRISE "God"? Refer to my commentary on (1), and it is clear that your statements in (4) ALSO hinge on "God's" knowledge being FINITE. A limited "God"..? That's about as "Greek" an idea as I've ever heard. (After all, the Olympian gods were little more than super-powered humans, who could be fooled by crafty mortals - think Odysseus!) Or how about the Norse gods, who could even be KILLED (as in the Balder myth...) At least the Greeks, Norse, ect. were honest enough to ADMIT the limitations of their deities. The men who wrote the Bible, sadly, LACKED such humility and claimed both omniscience and omnipotence for their big-g "God". Of course, such a claim required a STRONG "defense", if you will... a "SWORD" to back up the "pen." Thus was born the notion of "heresy" (i.e. lack of blind faith) and ultimately such credits to mankind as the doctrine of eternal Hell-fire for nonbelievers, the Holy Inquisition, ect. (I know you DON'T believe in the traditional vision of Hell, Don... but I'm sure you understand what I'm saying here nonetheless.) If I am to be punished in the next world for my disbelief... well, SO BE IT. At least in Hell (or "Heck" or whatever) I'll know I was being true to myself...
B-man
P.S. You can VERY EASILY regret things for which you are 100% responsible, Don. When I was a boy, I liked to torture small animals. I won't go into the details, but suffice it to say I was an imaginative little prick (and highly competitive with my little prick buddies - among whom I was a LEADER - especially when the frogs came out after a good rain...) Do I regret it? Hell, YES. It HURTS me now, to think about what I did (especially to cats, who are highly sentient, intelligent creatures.) Was I responsible for it? I KNEW in the back of my mind that it was WRONG. You figure out the rest... 'Nuff said.
|