i'd say no, give em their hearts desire nothing.
having said that my dads here
and he was a total skeptic..

Do men of BLIND FAITH deserve to be sucking
air??? (Thinking about (almost) the entire Republican party
here..!)
Or does the afterlife need their sheep-like stupidity, even as skeptics are the one who make life HERE on EARTH worthwhile? (Think science, medicine, technology yadda yadda... the Church didn't give us these things, pal...)
It's all relative, you see. A skeptical attitude bespeaks
a mind which seeks ANSWERS, and isn't satisfied
to munch grass and moo with the herd...
And if the afterlife IS "mooing with the herd", then
I don't want it... regardless of whether or not I
"deserve it."

Your skeptic-about-town,
B-man

Even the Catholic Church allows that those who aren't Catholic, or even Christian, may still be "saved" if they are a victim of 'Invincible Ignorance.'

People believe, or not believe, all sorts of things. But believing (or not) and knowing are two very different things. A skeptic is not any different from anyone else who believes they are right. Doesn't really matter what anyone believes, does it? We will all know sooner or later. Some of us prefer sooner without learning by the usual way, but that's not for everyone.

it's simple: everyone deserves everything they think they deserve... nothing else... (((Q)))