Copyrighted Logo

css menu by Css3Menu.com


 

Bruce's 5th book, a Home Study Course, is now available.
Books & Tapes by Bruce Moen
    Bruce's Blog now at http://www.afterlife-knowledge.com/blog....

  HomeHelpSearchLoginRegister  
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print
What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue? (Read 15631 times)
B-dawg
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 596
Missoula, Montana
Gender: male
What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Feb 16th, 2008 at 5:21am
 
LOTS.
Hawkeye mentioned in a response to my last thread that he thinks
that the NIU shooter deserves "forgiveness."
Hawkeye (and whoever else holds this view) whatever forgiveness
the shooter should get, is that which his victims are willing to give
him (to the extent that they are capable of forgiving, they're DEAD
after all) or the victim's families should give him. And they (victims OR family members) should only be expected to forgive, if they WANT to
forgive.
(If the law allowed it, I'd say they should be able to sue the shooter's mother for giving birth to him, or ENSLAVE her if she couldn't pay them in money - but that's another issue.)
If I were murdered, I would NEVER forgive the perpetrator (assuming
I still existed after death.) I would declare ETERNAL WAR on this
individual, as he had robbed me of everything that makes conscious
existence worthwhile.
He would have taken my POSSESSIONS from me...
He would have taken DRINK, and FOOD pleasures away from me...
He would have taken SEX away from me forever...
He would have taken away any chance I'd ever have, to
GET RICH and enjoy the glories of physical wealth...
And I would be sentenced to exist forever in an ethereal, ghostly, gassy, farty, wispy immaterial "spirit world" THANKS TO HIM. Forever robbed of what makes existence worthwhile to me, on account of HIS stupid problems, whatever they were.
...and I am supposed to be FRIENDS with him when he dies, and we meet again? Am I to be expected to reconcile with
him..? To be NICE to him...
To FORGIVE him???
I think not.
He wouldn't DESERVE it. It would DEMEAN me, not to spend the rest
of eternity getting EVEN with my murderer.
And so, the NIU shooter shouldn't be forgiven. And since you
WEREN'T his victim, what right have YOU (Hawkeye and others) to "forgive" him anyway?
You weren't "there" as they say...

B-man
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
blink
Ex Member


Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #1 - Feb 16th, 2008 at 3:18pm
 
There are many personal reasons that I can list as reasons to forgive, but your last comment indicates that you are seeking a more impersonal response, one which could be applied to anyone. Any reasonable example of forgiveness can be seen as a demonstration of an act which will benefit the forgiver in some way.

It is a heavy burden on the human heart, and others who bear witness, for resentments to play a starring role in our existence. Also, how can we know when we have put those grudges away? They often seem to have nine lives, just like cats, returning again and again. These resentments, no matter how important to us, can slow us down in many ways. Personal energy is required to experience and, if chosen, act on these resentments.

If a person is conscious enough, this burden can be examined. We ask, why carry this burden? At any juncture, the thought may arise, do I really need this?

Do I really want to carry this?

Angry thoughts may be put down, just exactly as if they were a heavy bag which has been slung over our shoulder during a long walk.

I think the human mind strives towards balance.
It is flexible on how to achieve it.
There is no reason to limit our options.
Forgiveness is one option.
It carries no weight.
It carries peace.

When we are ready to let go, we can choose forgiveness.

Who chose this war, we wonder; how did this happen?
Now it is our turn to choose.

If there is a time for war, there is also a time for peace.
This can be the time.
We say the word peace to ourselves.
It sounds good, better than it has in a long time.
We say it again.
Before we know it, there is peace.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Berserk2
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 844
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #2 - Feb 16th, 2008 at 7:05pm
 
Mitsuo Fuchida grew up hating Americans for their harsh treatment of Asian immigrants.   He became Japan’s top fighter pilot and led the epic raid on Pearl Harbor that engulfed us in WW2.  In fact it was Fuchida who shouted the famous code words “Tora, Tora, Tora,” that signaled the raid’s success and became the title of a Hollywood classic.  

Jake DeShazer was a member of the famed Doolittle raid, the first retaliatory strike on Japan.  He was shot down and captured by the Japanese as a POW.   During his captivity, Jake became a Christian and softened his harsh attitude towards the Japanese.  After his liberation, he wrote a widely distributed essay, “I was a Prisoner of the Japanese,” detailing his experiences of capture, conversion, and forgiveness.  Fuchida’s heart melted when he read this essay.  At his meeting with DeShazer in 1950, Fuchida converted from Buddhism to Christianity.  He later became a Christian evangelist in Japan.  Forgiveness can be a powerful agent of spiritual transformation.

B-man is right about one thing.  We cannot forgive others for the wrongs inflicted on others; we can only release our resentment of the culprit.  Forgiveness can only be offered by the offended or injured party and God.  Refusing to forgive traps the victim in his victim act and its accompanying bitterness.  Do you really want to give the offender that much power over your psyche?

Don
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
B-dawg
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 596
Missoula, Montana
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #3 - Feb 17th, 2008 at 12:56am
 
[quote author=Berserk2 link=1203153713/0#2 date=1203203109]Mitsuo Fuchida grew up hating Americans for their harsh treatment of Asian immigrants.   He became Japan’s top fighter pilot and led the epic raid on Pearl Harbor that engulfed us in WW2.  In fact it was Fuchida who shouted the famous code words “Tora, Tora, Tora,” that signaled the raid’s success and became the title of a Hollywood classic. 

Jake DeShazer was a member of the famed Doolittle raid, the first retaliatory strike on Japan.  He was shot down and captured by the Japanese as a POW.   During his captivity, Jake became a Christian and softened his harsh attitude towards the Japanese.  After his liberation, he wrote a widely distributed essay, “I was a Prisoner of the Japanese,” detailing his experiences of capture, conversion, and forgiveness.  Fuchida’s heart melted when he read this essay.  At his meeting with DeShazer in 1950, Fuchida converted from Buddhism to Christianity.  He later became a Christian evangelist in Japan.  Forgiveness can be a powerful agent of spiritual transformation.

B-man is right about one thing.  We cannot forgive others for the wrongs inflicted on others; we can only release our resentment of the culprit.  Forgiveness can only be offered by the offended or injured party and God.  Refusing to forgive traps the victim in his victim act and its accompanying bitterness.  Do you really want to give the offender that much power over your psyche?

Don
*****************
In the afterlife, where I would presumably meet the perp after HE
died, it would be cool if I had the option of making him my personal
a$$-kicking toy for a few hundred million years (or at least, do my very utmost to make him so!) Why should I allow
him to be HAPPY, after he'd confiscated the BEST part of my eternal
existence (i.e., the physical one???)

B-man

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Alan McDougall
Super Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 2104
South Africa
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #4 - Feb 17th, 2008 at 1:15am
 
Hi,

Fubar,

You get credit for being your own man and being honest and one can work from such a platform

alan
Back to top
 

Blessings and Light

Alan McDougall
WWW <a href= <a href=  
IP Logged
 
ultra
Full Member
***
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 119
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #5 - Feb 17th, 2008 at 11:09am
 



Hi F.B.,


Hmmm, those initials also stand for 'Faustian Bargain'.
I'm sure that is a meaningless coincidence.

You can get exactly what you want.
All you have to do is apply sufficient energy to your chosen vision.
Just decide what you want:
To kick someone's a$$, or
To have your own life without someone kicking yours.

It all begins right now.


- u




Back to top
 

"What the soul sees and has experienced, that it knows; the rest is appearance, prejudice and opinion."
   - Sri Aurobindo
 
IP Logged
 
vajra
Ex Member


Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #6 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 12:41pm
 
Cry Failure to forgive is it seems another of those ways we in a wholly practical and external as well as internal ways we bring suffering on ourselves and others. We somehow get sucked into thinking that we're different - that if we give in to the urge we won't afterwards feel bad about it, or won't be pursued by others intent on giving us an even larger piece of what we gave them.

It's perhaps worth pointing out that that Japanese gentleman above while stated as being Buddhist was in acting the way he did wholly at odds with the most basic of Buddhist teaching....
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
hawkeye
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 886
canada
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #7 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 2:12pm
 
FB, The shooter does not need your or any one elses forgivness. Only his own. Thats the only way he will heal himself of what effect he has had upon these other souls. I would think that the ones he killed have forgiven him already.  Where you and I hold some what of a similar ideas are about the church. I don't need Jesus to forgive anything that I have done that might be disagreeable to what is portrayed as his beliefs. I only need to forgive myself and to except the responsibility of what I have done, or do, upon others. I was more concerned about your need to express a desire to kill others who have done nothing to you or yours. Sound very twisted and immature to me. To me it sounds like you are in some kind of need to create an effect when you say thing like this. Perhaps more acknowleddment when you were younger, when you spoke or had ideas, could have helped. Such an angry young man.
Joe
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
dave_a_mbs
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 1655
central california
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #8 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 5:25pm
 
Hi B-Man-

I'm basically very self-serving. The process of carrying hatred means that I would have to adjust my internals so as to delete a general feeling of goodwill and a bearable lifestyle, and in its place UI'd have to put a contingency, that life is OK if and only if the world has kept some SOB away from me, or permanently deleted him.

For someone to make me alter my naturally comfortable state once is a nuisance. The severity of the nuisance depends on just what they did to me. That seems bad enough. However, once done, it's difficult to do more than basic damage control.

For someone then to make me periodically drag out that event and look at it in order to maintain a level of rage and resentment is an additional insult. However, I can get rid of the whole mess by "forgiveness".  In this sense, forgiving does not mean that it was OK, that they can do it again, nor that I in any way am interested in havinf them in my world. It means only that I have better things to do with my life than holding a brick and awaiting a chance to whack them.

Conversely, so long as I am busy resenting and hating, I am using up energy that would far better be employed in having fun. By that kind of attitude, I'm letting them spoil more of my life, both now and into the future. Carrying a load of negativity thus keeps the unplessant event in present time.

In this specific sense, forgiveness is a self serving thing, and is the only way to get the event out of present time and to allow it to go into the past.

And this is also true if the bad guy happens to have absorbed a couple 7.62x25 Mag-Safe - except that in that case it is myself that I must forgive. After all, sometimes you get the bear, and sometimes the bear gets you.  (I'm more inclined to be bothered if I miss.)

So forgiveness is a weapon against evil. It is counter-intuitive, but it works. I generally use forgiveness as a clinical tool by which to restore a woman's sexuality after she has had 20 years to brood over being raped by Daddy at 10 years of age, or the equivalent.

The next line to that lesson is to be practical - If a dog bites you, and if you can't have it put down or locked up, then there's no reason to put your hand back in its mouth.

dave
Back to top
 

life is too short to drink sour wine
WWW  
IP Logged
 
B-dawg
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 596
Missoula, Montana
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #9 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 6:27pm
 
[quote author=dave_a_mbs link=1203153713/0#8 date=1203369932]Hi B-Man-

I'm basically very self-serving. The process of carrying hatred means that I would have to adjust my internals so as to delete a general feeling of goodwill and a bearable lifestyle, and in its place UI'd have to put a contingency, that life is OK if and only if the world has kept some SOB away from me, or permanently deleted him.

For someone to make me alter my naturally comfortable state once is a nuisance. The severity of the nuisance depends on just what they did to me. That seems bad enough. However, once done, it's difficult to do more than basic damage control.

For someone then to make me periodically drag out that event and look at it in order to maintain a level of rage and resentment is an additional insult. However, I can get rid of the whole mess by "forgiveness".  In this sense, forgiving does not mean that it was OK, that they can do it again, nor that I in any way am interested in havinf them in my world. It means only that I have better things to do with my life than holding a brick and awaiting a chance to whack them.

Conversely, so long as I am busy resenting and hating, I am using up energy that would far better be employed in having fun. By that kind of attitude, I'm letting them spoil more of my life, both now and into the future. Carrying a load of negativity thus keeps the unplessant event in present time.

In this specific sense, forgiveness is a self serving thing, and is the only way to get the event out of present time and to allow it to go into the past.

And this is also true if the bad guy happens to have absorbed a couple 7.62x25 Mag-Safe - except that in that case it is myself that I must forgive. After all, sometimes you get the bear, and sometimes the bear gets you.  (I'm more inclined to be bothered if I miss.)

So forgiveness is a weapon against evil. It is counter-intuitive, but it works. I generally use forgiveness as a clinical tool by which to restore a woman's sexuality after she has had 20 years to brood over being raped by Daddy at 10 years of age, or the equivalent.

The next line to that lesson is to be practical - If a dog bites you, and if you can't have it put down or locked up, then there's no reason to put your hand back in its mouth.

dave
*****************
Of course, my specific example had me as having been MURDERED
and therefore dead (and presumably condemned to being a non-corporeal cloud of gas in the "spirit world" - still aware, but having had everything taken from me by the perp.
What "fun" would there be for me there? To float around and look at
things, reminiscing maybe...
But not be able to DO anything?
What would there be for me, but to await the arrival of my enemy...
And plot against his happiness, so at least I'd have the knowledge that he wasn't ENTIRELY my lord and master?

B-man
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
B-dawg
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 596
Missoula, Montana
Gender: male
One more thing, people...
Reply #10 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 6:37pm
 
The justification of forgiveness as a virtue is, well - a bit
WORDY ("soften your heart to let in the pain", "make peace
with your oppressor to make peace with yourself"(???), yadda
yadda...) These statements are also murky, and counter-intuitive
to the point of sounding like sophistries (which I suspect they are.)
Also, they make a convenient cop-out for intimidated weaklings,
or cowards. What a convenient way to "wash your hands"! Can this be a coincidence??? I doubt it.
I've found that the most profound truths, could generally be iterated
in ten words or less. (I.E. "he who trades liberty for security,
deserves (and gets) neither.") And there was no ambiguity, and
they can easily be intuitively understood by anyone. (i.e. "right - BACKED BY MIGHT - makes right!") They are also crystal clear
the first time you hear them, no mental gymnastics required...
So forgive(!) me, if I find the assertion that "forgiveness is the
best thing you can do" to fall a bit flat.

B-man
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
vajra
Ex Member


Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #11 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 8:46pm
 
Wink Sounds like we'd better talk again in 15 years.....
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
blink
Ex Member


Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #12 - Feb 18th, 2008 at 8:57pm
 
How about these?

If we could read the secret history of our enemies,
we should find in each man's life
sorrow and suffering enough
to disarm all hostility.
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow

I will fight no more forever.
Chief Joseph

Peace hath higher tests of manhood than battle ever knew.
John Greenleaf Whittier

There was never a good war or a bad peace.
Benjamin Franklin

Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
dave_a_mbs
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 1655
central california
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #13 - Feb 19th, 2008 at 12:16am
 
The only problem with creating a peaceful situation is that we are today in one that we have to deal with. It's the old problem of discovering that you have a tiger by the tail - Ooops!

Actually, there is excellent reason, from various kinds of reports and such, that once dead, if we have lived a life without harm to others, our next lives too will be without harm. When we look more deeply at the "peaceful Buddhists" who were mistreated by the Chinese when they invaded Tibet, we discover that they are receiving the same treatment that they gave to the Bon Lamaists when Buddhism rose to power.

In my personal case, I recall being blown up, and I have an association with poison gasses and artillery. My present life has amply given me the chance to discover these karmic connections. Try as I might, I am unable to guarantee that I will have a life of safety. So I take the posture of an armed truce with the potential bad guys.

I guess that the other two extremes would be people like Edgar Cayce, who never had more than financial worries, and a bit of health issues at times. And the antithesis, the terrorist suicide bombers who seem to feel that national pride, religious zeal, or some other superficial factor is more important than human life.

As for me, I doubt I'll be around in 15 years, Vajra, so you'll have to work this one out with Brendan.

However - I recall that a large number of unhappy souls that I've worked with, especially entities who have been terrified of letting go of their hosts,  have been uhappy because they've dragged the causes of their own deaths into the afterlife. and are clinging to them through rage and hatred, and can't figure out why things don't work so well.

It seems to me that everybody is essentially God. But some of them don't know it, and need to be "adjusted" for my own well being, That's somewhat reasonable. In my life, I've been slapped down for doing stupid things, and I suppose that I couold apply the same method, but that doesn't mean that I don't love the poor miscreants. I just believe in tough love. Just like I feel for mosquitos. (Swat!)

dave
Back to top
 

life is too short to drink sour wine
WWW  
IP Logged
 
hawkeye
Super Member
*****
Offline


Afterlife Knowledge Member

Posts: 886
canada
Gender: male
Re: What's wrong with "forgiveness" as a virtue?
Reply #14 - Feb 19th, 2008 at 1:41pm
 
FB, I wanted to get back on this thread as the other one is really about the girls and their problems. Where I have the problem is your need to express a desire to kill. Not that is makes a differance if you use a gun or a needle. Its still a desire to kill. You even mention a desire to penalise his mother for giving birth to him. I have hunting rifles myself. Its the hand guns that are used for killing humans. That where I have a problem. As for you having guns... well you have express your thoughts very well. I don't personaly think you should have them with your kill, kill, mentality. I would think that your just as dangerous as he was. I sure wouldnt want someone to go into your house and take what guns you have mind you. You have the "right" to own them. I bet your a collector or something like that. Knives also? Your probably ( or were) a darn good army man. (Or did they not even let you in?) You know all brain washed into the whole kill,kill. You know, a good killing man. Did ya bully in school? To me you seem like an open book. A dangerous open book. How interesting it will be for you on the other side I would imagine. I wonder if there are flies to pull the wings off over there for you to have your fun with? Or am I all wrong FB. If I am, my apologies. I could have you all wrong. I mean no harm to you. It could be that your not twisted. You could be 100% USA grade A, #1, normal.  And if so,  could you offer me your "forgiveness"? For I am a judgemental person with weeknesses of my own.
Joe
Joe
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 
Send Topic Print


This is a Peer Moderated Forum. You can report Posting Guideline violations.