Conversation Board | |
https://afterlife-knowledge.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.cgi
Forums >> Afterlife Knowledge >> The brain versus the soul https://afterlife-knowledge.com/cgi-bin/yabb/YaBB.cgi?num=1209492994 Message started by LaffingRain on Apr 29th, 2008 at 2:16pm |
Title: The brain versus the soul Post by LaffingRain on Apr 29th, 2008 at 2:16pm rondele wrote on Mar 28th, 2008 at 2:54pm:
_______ Hi Rondele, we seem to be studying the same areas of thought so I thought I'd do a take off you. if the brain which goes haywire is not our true self, then whatever is true returns to source. From studying who and what we are, trying to ascertain that, it's a life long pursuit as you mentioned, it continue to become potentialized in the afterlife areas. Dalmer was a study of mine also, but he is just one person who went haywire. Another study of the criminal brain, Alan, did show distinct differences. Curiously, we study some persons, who appear to be soul-less. (no conscious, not knowing right from wrong.) then if we look closer at psychology, at what we know, and if we look at how the human repeats certain behaviors learned, we can see the brain functions for the soul or spirit as a computer. We come into the world innocent of programs. Our parents and teachers soon tell us what to think and what to do, thus we get programmed. In that sense we are all responsible for the crime in the world. Instead of picking out a murderer to study, the problem can be viewed that not only is single units programmed to kill, but we have the case of nation against nation resulting in killing, yet sanctioned by government. Still, taking the individual who is soul-less from ACIM viewpoint. Dalmer, for instance. It was reported he ate his victims so that his victims would achieve immortality through him. most twisted and sick, but no more twisted and sick than to take a look at our legal killing constructs. In this regard we could conjecture we all share in the world which we are responsible to find out how the brain can get so twisted and not blame everything on God for creating an imperfect world where we can get killed for merely being a part of it. so I say, we are on the right track to be discussing the horrors we see around us. (an aside, Alfred, your mother is delightful, she wanted to experience this way to go, I conjecture, it is sometimes easier to transition slowly back into the spirit realm, as with the brain declining this way. Part of the care you took of her, was tremendously adding to your own growth in PUL and understanding, I love u started this thread, sorry to shanghie it.) So the killing machines need to be understood, how it got twisted. We all know a soldier can be trained to kill easily enough. boot camp is an example. With Dalmer, I believe he took the Oneness concept a bit too far! as to his soul plan, I'm certain he did not enter the Earth Plane to do this dirty deed. So I'd say if I thought some on it, in terms of what ACIM tells me, he felt so alienated, so separated from everyone and everything, as well God, he felt he could add something unto himself by eating his victims, and do them a favor at the same time by granting them immortality within his body. Obviously, he wasn't thinking correctly and his twisted thought forms which he produced are not the truth of our being, and will be dissolved consequently in the lowest astral. His basic essence, that without personality, that without twisted thought forms, gets distilled once more back into it's pure essence. I have heard there are some rare cases, where such a one manages to completely break free of the disc connections, where guidance of higher intuition, the soul, the oversoul, God, whatever we call it, where the sense of disconnection is too intense, nothing had been gained from such a life, and so nothing useful which could continue into a plus factor in the afterlife. We're supposed to bring our individual gifts back to the disc, I don't know, but it seems Dalmer probably never did a kind deed to animal or man, and so no gifts to add to the humanity. In the end we can't say for certain what happens to him, or even if there is a real person inside of him. we could say he is an example of a lost soul that society bred but not God. In tring to figure these things out, we could say in the beginning we broke off or separated from God, and that very separation caused us to try and prove to God we could live without God, we could make death real; this is what is called ego thinking by the Course. As you and I knowthe ego can be a vicious thing. The only thing we have to work with in the Earth Plan is Free will. The choice to do good or evil, or as ACIM and other sources explain perceiving our world correctly or incorrectly, what is called true perception and false perception. keeping in mind that true or false perception is the road to knowledge of God, but is not knowledge itself, nor is it the wisdom that a soul can gain by incarnating here. in essence we are all perceiving differently, either truly or falsely. In future times I project care will taken to teach all children a spiritual path and this through constant attendance within PUL, within disapline. For too long, it's my thought, the kid takes on the errors of the parents...we might want to study the preventative medicine rather than the disease if we're looking to end the killing. |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by Alan McDougall on Apr 29th, 2008 at 7:23pm
Hek!! Alysia and Rondele,
Quote:
I blush and hang my head in shame What is is "ACIM" ease the pain of my ignorance please. As for God only creating perfection I must diagree. just look at this creation of eat kill or be eaten and kill. Surely an omniscient God could have come up with a better way of putting fuel. energy into our bodies. "But then I do like my steak" alan |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by spooky2 on Apr 29th, 2008 at 9:39pm
I think the fundamental problem remains and will ever remain, when it is assumed that God created everything, then God created as well brains, the society, and all the (sometimes terrible) things which follow from that.
The only solution is, to let go of the traditional attributes of "God". For example, when we attribute God to be "good", then we will not get it together with all those bad things happening. So either we don't make this attributation, or we make a difference between the godly goodness, which we don't know what it is, and the common-sense goodness. So, what's left is, as Alysia said, "to find out how the brain can get so twisted", well, to find out what's happening, and why. The final "why" though will not be answered, at least not in words. But we won't get very far when we make the brain responsible for the bad deeds, and the soul for the good deeds. You know, we all would be angels, and our flaws would come from our brains, which we are not responsible for. That doesn't work. As well the term "soulless" is unusable. When is a person soulless? When a person has killed one? Or two? Or more? And, when a person is declared as soulless, then it isn't a person anymore, but only a body? It could be killed then without being a crime, cause it would be just a body. No, that doesn't work neither. Spooky |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by Alan McDougall on Apr 29th, 2008 at 10:35pm Spooky, Alysia I agree and restate what I said in a previous thread that if a soul is created in perfection it couldn’t have potential. It is perfect and how can one improve on perfection?. Souls are created "innocent" not "perfect" with almost infinite potential upward into the Light or downward into the Dark. As a matter of fact, I have come across some evil entities during both my NDE and OBE episodes. Only God is perfect!! Another absolute fact that contradicts perfect creation is the awful reality of the mess our world is in. Alysia Quote Quote:
That dear old mislead Dahmer ate his victims for altruistic reasons is news to me, but far out as this might be what the hek!!! Was he doing when he sodomised these young men/boys kept them alive for his pleasure (The only way he could get sexually aroused)? Then slaughtered them storing their decaying dead bodies all over his stinking apartment and continued to perform unspeakable sexual depravity on the rotting remains of his victims. On sentencing, he told the court when trying to explain why he did what he did he said. "IT WAS PURE EVIL THAT MADE HIM DO WHAT HE DID". There was nothing wrong with his brain; he had a fairly normal upbringing. Countless people grow up in much much worse circumstances of abuse violence and deprivation than he did and become normal good member of society Why the difference, HE WAS INTRINSICALLY EVIL AND SAID SO HIMSELF" alan |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by blink on Apr 30th, 2008 at 7:37am
I think we get into perilous territory when we begin to discuss the merits of another person's soul. Another person's soul has value beyond measure, in my opinion.
I think we have to separate the deeds from the doer. Ultimately, that is all we can do. We can set up social structures to support those who show these tendencies early in life. It is always a tragedy when a person takes the wrong path, especially when it could have been avoided by earlier intervention. There are no redeeming qualities to a path such as this case you speak of. However, I think it is important to recognize that we are so shamed by belonging to our tribe of human beings, who practice acts of violence and humiliation all over the world, that we don't really want to own this as ours. But, without a doubt, even this soul brought some happiness to someone along the way. I think we have to believe in a God who, having allowed Dalmer/Dahmer (sp?) to come into existence, has the mercy which is required to balance this fact. As I see it, there is little mercy for the weak in this world. There is, instead, an eventual end to this brief life. Often, that is merciful beyond description. So merciful that we long for it occasionally, for an end to all the painful experiences. We wonder why we are brought into a world of pain, through pain, by pain. There seem to be no answers. But, assuredly, as humans, we are children. Why does it seem that no one is watching us? No one looking out for us so that we don't do terrible things? That's a very good question. love, blink |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by LaffingRain on Apr 30th, 2008 at 12:51pm Alan McDougall wrote on Apr 29th, 2008 at 7:23pm:
hey Alan my friend, I am blushing over here too. thanks for the read. sometimes it is not blushing, it is feeling the horror of it all and bursting out crying. but talk is good rather than hiding from it. ACIM is A Course In Miracles. despite where it came from, how it got here, all of us are needing a miracle on the planet Earth. sometimes we want a miracle on the body, to be healed. some of us get one, others will take an entire lifetime to heal themselves on the body, or just let the disease take them out. It's better to heal our minds and spirits first, then the body does not become a problem to heal. the reason I like ACIM, is I always believed in miracles to become everyday occurrences since I was very young. its sort of a faith attitude that we don't settle for less, as we are so well loved for coming here, this is what we need to know and feel to make changes. Alan, I hang my head in shame too. I know how u feel, but these feelings will pass, they are not permanent feelings, they are motivating feelings towards keeping the faith. God in a way turned us loose down here, with the choice factor..and when things get tough, the tough get going. when things like this bother you, you are waking up. you should be glad then. Think about the bible what it says..JC was sent by God into our material world. If God were already manifest in our physical world would a Son of God be necessary to send, to tell us of eternal life? and the resurrection proves the body can be restored to life. and so do accounts of NDE's, should be evidence the body is just a form the spirit uses. The main message of JC that we missed here is we can be like him, we can do miracles because the message missing from the bible was that we are ALL Sons of God to develop potential for miracles. Sons to mean both genders. my feeling is we wasted enough time on this planet repeating wars. I think we are stepping up our vibrations and I'm going to enjoy the ride! |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by recoverer on Apr 30th, 2008 at 12:53pm
Below is from Wikipedia (At the bottom of this post.) It shows that Dahmer might've had some issues at an early age. The fact of how his father forced him to join the Army shows the possibility of a father who was difficult to deal with.
I believe this World is a part of our soul's developmental process, so I believe it is a mistake to call it imperfect. Negativity is a possibility, because without the play of contrasts this World includes, we couldn't have the lessons we need to learn. I do believe that the human race is engaging in too much negativity. We weren't supposed to go this far astray. We need to improve things. Regarding Dahmer, with the World being the way it is, some people are liable to go astray. This is proven over and over again. I don't mean to state that some people were completely lacking in choice. I had a dream the other night that related to the human conscious. The dream showed that at first our conscious is very noticeable. Sometimes people don't listen to it for whatever reason. The more they choose not to do so, the harder it becomes to hear, until it seems like a distant stranger. Therefore, even a child in a difficult life situation has a choice in the beginning. Of course things tend to work out better when a lot of positive choices and influences are available. Even if a person makes bad choices, I believe it is important to open our hearts to such a person when such a person moves in another direction. I don't like to think in terms of forgiveness, because there is a bit of judgement involved when one thinks in terms of forgiveness. Once a person/soul decides to move in the direction of the light, it is more of a matter of such a person/soul forgiving itself. Once a person/soul decides to move in a positive direction, that which can be judged no longer exists. Perhaps there might be some karmic responsibilities, but this is a different matter. Something any responsible and loving soul would want to attend to. I believe it is significant that we start out as light, for the sake of a greater good get confused for a short while, and for the rest of eternity abide as the beautiful light beings we are. No sense in getting hung up because some of us end up getting more confused than others. Perhaps the souls who take on incarnations with all kinds of negative influences should be given credit. From Wikipedia: ""Early life Dahmer was born in West Allis, Wisconsin, to Lionel, an analytical chemist, and Joyce Dahmer. At age 8 his family moved to Bath, Ohio, where he attended Revere High School. Dahmer dissected dead animals as a child, and by his teenage years was an alcoholic loner.[citation needed] Dahmer attended Ohio State University, but dropped out after two terms. Dahmer's father then forced him to enlist in the Army, where he was to serve for a six-year enlistment; he was discharged after two, due to his excessive drinking. When the Army discharged Dahmer in 1981, they provided him with a plane ticket to anywhere in the country. Dahmer told police he couldn't go home to face his father, so he headed to Miami Beach, Florida, because he was "tired of the cold." He spent most of his time there at a hospital but was kicked out shortly after for drinking.[1] In 1982, Dahmer moved in with his grandmother in West Allis, where he lived for six years. In August of that year, he was arrested for exposing himself at a state fair. In September 1986, he was charged again with public exposure after two boys accused him of masturbating in public. This time he was sentenced to a year in prison, of which he served 10 months. In the summer of 1988 Dahmer's grandmother asked him to move out due to his late nights and foul smells from the basement. He then found an apartment on Milwaukee's West side. On September 25, 1988, he was arrested for sexually fondling a 13-year-old boy in Milwaukee, for which he served 10 months of a one year sentence in a work release camp. He was required to register as a sex offender. He convinced the judge that he needed therapy, and he was released with a five-year probation on good behavior. Shortly thereafter, he began a string of murders that would end with his arrest in 1991."" |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by recoverer on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:05pm
Alan:
If you don't consider the below more deeply, you only stunt your own growth. You said you've seen evil beings during out of body experiences. Did you take a look back far into their lives, and see that they started out divine like everybody else? Did you take a look into their future and see the glorious moment when they chose to move back in the direction of the light? Have you considered the possibility that there might've been times when you saw beings who represented the projection of your own beliefs? Consider Bruce Moen's Banshee story in his second book, and other similar cases. Could you truly be completely happy in a heavenly realm for all of eternity, if you knew that there were other parts of your self that abided in lower realms? To simply suggest that they get what they deserve, won't enable any being who lives completely according to love to feel satisfied. How could a being who lives completely according to love, ever abandon other parts of itself? Alan McDougall wrote on Apr 29th, 2008 at 10:35pm:
|
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by LaffingRain on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:12pm spooky2 wrote on Apr 29th, 2008 at 9:39pm:
the soul less thing is just a theory, that is to say I do believe in certain places of the Earth, societies brain washing is an example, that this has been accomplished on certain people, in native tribes, secret societies there have been a few reports of zombies produced. I know of one case where a man's soul exited his body, yet his body got up and prepared to make his usual routine of getting coffee made before keeling over in death. He had a hatchet in his head. bodies can live like vegetables, but there is no soul in there. In the same way studies have been made upon certain extreme cases that a criminal truly does not know right from wrong, and this is determined by the courts and shrinks, and this is what I meant by "having no conscious." they, these RARE cases think what they did was "right." So we may be looking at how the ego always thinks it's right, no matter what harm it has done upon another, it blocks out the truth. Soul less does not work Spooky, when we are considering our oneness within PUL, which is all encompassing. PUL is understanding our criminal minds, by probing their minds with a Light. Also, it won't work to try and say that we can fight evil this way, as a force of itself, this doesn't work either. and it doesn't work very well to say God allows evil. I think you're on the right track, that we change our conception of God, maybe to a sound working principles of action based on PUL's authority. It's part of the feeling separate from God and treating God as a personage, to hold God accountable for atrocities here. This is why ACIM will say we are here, having ourselves a nightmare. When we awaken, the nightmare begins to disappear as reality sets in. We are waking up, and you, are one of those who awakens ahead of the others, my opinion. |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by LaffingRain on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:32pm
alan said: HE WAS INTRINSICALLY EVIL AND SAID SO HIMSELF"
perhaps this is taking the easy way of thinking though Alan. because if Evil stands alone as a force that it's opposite force cannot subdue, what are we to do to change the world for the better? that is the question rather than saying oh, he was evil. there may be evil and have to live with it. what I'm saying, most criminals display a tendency to commit worse crimes as they age. in childhood, they often abuse and kill animals. the parents turn their face away, thinking it's just a phase, the judge gives a lite fine, no counseling necessary for abuse of animals in some cases. then there was those school shootings in Colorado. parents and others saw some clues that this was coming, that it was a possibility the boys were planning this. their computers were full of violent plans if anybody had noticed. too often the thought is "boys will be boys." so I'm relating we work on Earth to watch the children closer, and maybe some of this can be prevented. I can't get my head around born killers idea, or born evil, but I can get my head around how evil can grow if not nipped in the bud at the first clue something is not quite right. I'm the type of person holds the parent responsible for not noticing what their kids are capable of becoming. It's all fine to say evil is incarnated, that some are just flat evil, but that's no solution. we need to take responsibility, that we are all capable of murder if we don't help each other understand the working of the mind, and the ego can get out of control here. |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by Alan McDougall on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:35pm
Hi, all,
I for one would not let a Jeffrey Dharma baby-sit my children or grandchildren, would you? And if his type ever committed the same horrors on members of my family, I would revert to total subjectivity and basic human nature and really want the depraved beast/monster done way with. Closure is so important for the relatives of victims of these kinds of atrocities and the best way is to execute them and send them into the afterlife for God to deal with . Of course, this could be construed as murdering the murderer , but guys it is done much more humanly in most USA states by lethal injection and should not be equated with the horrors of Dharma method and co of disposing of precious human life. Of course, this thread is now treading on extremely sensitive personal issues and could descend into a non-ending debate on the pros and cons of the death penalty, so I for one will nor expand on this never-ending argument . Keeping these depraved murderers of the innocent in prison for a life time leaves the victims family with no closure and the constant knowledge that they can continue to live and get state medical treatment and food. But God forbid that anyone out their has ever to be faced with this hideous dilemma. I RESTATE MY POSITION THAT THE SOUL IS NEITHER CREATED GOOD OR EVIL BUT IN A NEUTRAL STATE OF INNOCENCE THAT ALLOWS FOR GROWTH AND POTENTIAL. ALL SOULS START OUT WITH A FREE WILL AND “NEUTRAL INNOCENCE” WHICH ALLOWS FOR POTENTIAL AND EACH CHOSE THEIR OWN LIFE PATH. alan |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by LaffingRain on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:53pm wrote on Apr 30th, 2008 at 7:37am:
You're backing me up about the prevention early on Blink. I do believe the same, in mercy, and separating the deed from the doer. very good points. We could imagine then Dalmer getting counseling on the other side rather than being in hell forever. I do believe there are those beings specifically trained on the other side to work with criminals. as a mystic, I actually met one of them. Imagine that! a social worker spirit she was. knew exactly how to untangle the thoughts of a rapist..all i had to do was drive him over to her and she took him in hand. so I can agree with you, we cannot judge accurately here, what goes on in this other dimension after we exit the body; we can only get a glimpse now and then and be glad for it. Still, I think it's good to talk about it, we might be able to help each other figure out something. if only one person is helped by our openly discussing our thoughts, maybe it can help the shift in consciousness occurring. |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by recoverer on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:56pm
Alan:
I believe things are set up so that all of us eventually return to God. Numerous trustworthy sources support this idea. It is true that each of have free will, but eventually each of us will come to the point where we find that there is only one good choice. A choice that enables us to live according to happiness, peace, goodness, beauty and love for all of eternity. Even people who get lost for a while do so because they weren't able to find the love that all of us want. To suggest that my last statement is false, is to suggest that there are little children in this World who aren't seeking love. Do such little children exist, or do they all have a natural inner yearning for love that the circumstances of their lives sometimes don't provide? Regarding the family members of a person who gets murdered, eventually each of these family members will find themselves in a heavenly realm. Will such spirits continue to have bad feeling towards the person who killed one of these family members when all of them now find themselves in a realm of perfection, or will the love and wisdom they live according to cause them to want to see this person move onto the light? If they hold on to bad feelings, they won't be able to move on to the light. |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by Alan McDougall on Apr 30th, 2008 at 2:13pm
Recoverer,
Note!! Dharma said it was evil that made him do what he did. (I did not say this he did) Quote:
Now I must take issue that all beings started out perfect and divine. Man! one simply can never ever improve on divine perfection, as this is the ultimate stage of a souls journey not the beginning stage. A soul that is both divine can never become less than divine and perfect. There is no potential with this scenario other than an eternal downward spiral. A soul is indeed created divinely and in "perfect neutral innocence and with its "God given free will can chose good or evil". But believing and knowing what I know is somehow stunting my growth I don’t think so,. Yes indeed, there are many growing pains and lessons on my path back to eternal union with the DIVINE LIGHT. Alysia, You quoted Quote: Quote:
Absolutely true JC said "we can do the things he did and greater still" I have seen unexplainable miracles in my own life and backyard. Yes we must embrace life with vigor, and joy and have as much fun as possible while here so long as our fun does not hurt others or animals. We should meditate on the good things we possess in life and not the negative and we will reach a state of peaceful bliss alan |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by LaffingRain on Apr 30th, 2008 at 2:15pm Alan McDougall wrote on Apr 30th, 2008 at 1:44pm:
more from Alan, a consensus sort of to this thread: I RESTATE MY POSITION THAT THE SOUL IS NEITHER CREATED GOOD OR EVIL BUT IN A NEUTRAL STATE OF INNOCENCE THAT ALLOWS FOR GROWTH AND POTENTIAL. ALL SOULS START OUT WITH A FREE WILL AND “NEUTRAL INNOCENCE” WHICH ALLOWS FOR POTENTIAL AND EACH CHOSE THEIR OWN LIFE PATH. ______ I'll just add my somewhat vacant 2 cents...let us be the ones to help the Dahmer's make another choice. thanks to everyone here helping me see more clearly. :) |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by recoverer on Apr 30th, 2008 at 2:48pm
Alan:
For what purpose do you believe this World was created? Regarding Dahmer saying evil caused him to do what he did, considering the things he did, could his word be trusted? I believe that in order for the contrasts to exist that enable the lesson this World provides to exist, the possibility of evil coming from any of us exists. For example, we can't fully understand what humility means without understanding what arrogance means. Perhaps Dahmer was influenced by unfriendly spirits. Perhaps spirits who used to be human and went down the wrong path before dying. If his consciousness was already manifesting in a similar way, perhaps partly because of the influences of a difficult father, perhaps an unfriendly spirit or two was energetically attracted to him. I've noticed that unfriendly spirits like to pick on children. Perhaps a sign of their lack of true strength. When I was five years old I lived accross the street from another five year old boy that was a monster. At the age of five he did some terrible things. It probably didn't help that both of his parents were alcoholics. Did such a young child have enough knowledge to make good decisions? |
Title: Re: The brain versus the soul Post by recoverer on Apr 30th, 2008 at 2:56pm
Alysia said: "I'll just add my somewhat vacant 2 cents...let us be the ones to help the Dahmer's make another choice."
I'm with you Alysia. :) I believe the statement "love your neighbor as yourself" goes a long way. Even when it's applied to those who forget it. It isn't the negative actions we love. It's the spirit who makes use of them. Just as a loving parent continues to love a child who goes astray. Until we get to the point where we can love in such a way, we won't love completely. |
Conversation Board » Powered by YaBB 2.4! YaBB © 2000-2009. All Rights Reserved. |